The first time I saw this episode 30
years ago I was like the vast majority of viewers: I genuinely believed
everything we saw in this story was the complete, unfiltered truth about the
Cigarette-Smoking Man. This astonished the author Glen Morgan (his first solo
script while James Wong made his directorial debut) who had pretty much made it
clear in the final minutes that none of it was canon.
Frohike says in the very last moments
that: "So far, this is based only on a story I read in one of my weekly
subscriptions that rang a few bells." In other words he found in a copy of
Roman A Clef which was thrown in the trash and assumes that it is the fully
story behind the Smoking Man.
It should be clear that there was
confusion behind the scenes. Morgan and Chris Carter had many disagreements
about which parts were true and William B. Davis was confused and frustrated by
it. And if the behind the scenes people were baffled by which was true and what
wasn't, one can hardly blame the viewer.
In truth I should have picked up on it
because so much of what we see in this episode blatantly contradicts so much of
what we've already seen in the mythology so far. The Smoking Man is apparently
in his 20s in the first flashback in 1962 but we remember the flashback in
Apocrypha where he and Bill Mulder were already hard at work covering up the
conspiracy in 1953. When Mulder
confronted Smoking Man for the first time he told him: "I've watched Presidents
die", not that he pulled the trigger himself. Reading so much of the talk
of everyone, including the conversation between him and Deep Throat in
Christmas of 1991, no one in the conspiracy knows anything about aliens and its
all basically Cold War paranoia. And of course the idea that CSM is responsible
for the Bills never winning the Super Bowl, rigging the Oscar nominations and
the Olympics is the kind of conspiracy ridden drivel that you think not even
Mulder believes.
The reason that Musings is one of the
all-time masterpieces on The X-Files is because it basically pokes fun
at the major idea behind the series itself, very much in the kind of
deconstructionist way that Glen's brother Darin famously did during this tenure
on the series. (Glen actually gives a blink and you miss it tribute to his
brother by referring to him in a magazine story that has an article titled:
"Where the Hell Is Darin Morgan?, a question many X-philes themselves were
asking around this time.) The difference is one of nuance and how the comedy
plays out. In all of Darin Morgan's script the deconstruction style was done
with so many open jokes and parodies that the fourth wall was all but torn
down. Glen's deconstruction, by contrast, barely draws attention to itself and
is done more in a series of subtle nuances to things that don't refer to The
X-Files but rather other films and TV shows.
The opening scene where a young
Smoking Man is brought into meet with the military and is questioned on whether
he was involved in the assassination of Lumbaba and Rafael Trujillo – political
assassinations the CIA is long suspected in – is a direct pastiche one of the
early scenes of Apocalypse Now. Oliver Stone's work is referenced, not
just in the obvious parallel to JFK but films like Nixon and The
Doors. So much of the references to aliens in such dismissive tone is
clearly a dig at NBC's Dark Skies which was airing at the same time and
took a historical look at so much what The X-Files was doing. And of
course the Smoking Man's monologue is an incredible piss-take on Forest Gump
which is honestly the funniest thing in the entire episode. (And I really
wish Tom Hanks had said it now.)
There are even references to other
actual spies. When Smoking Man meets with Lee Harvey Oswald, Oswald refers to
him as "Mr. Hunt." This is clearly a reference to E. Howard Hunt, a
former CIA agent best known for breaking into the Watergate Hotel as part of
the Plumbers, has been linked in some circles to the Kennedy assassination and
– wait for it! – wrote spy novels under a pseudonym. The scene where Smoking
Man lectures Hoover for his failures to track Martin Luther King's leftward
trajectory is very much involved with not just the wiretapping of the Civil
Rights movement but the theory held by many that the FBI had King killed just
like they did many of the Black Panthers. That Smoking Man is inserted in so
many of these real life events – a la Forest Gump – doesn't detract from the
very really possibility that there is more than a grain of truth to it.
Robert Shearman in his rave of this
episode says that part of what makes it brilliant is that:
It sends up The X-Files' ability to
find answers, suggesting that the entire spine of the backstory is never to be
fully explained. That, in spite of the shows by-line, there is no truth out
there. The whole point of The X-Files is ambiguity.
It promises to be a character study
and it turns out to be anything but...because there is no character to study.
Fittingly I agree with some of this
idea but not all of it. Morgan may not be pulling back the curtain to reveal
the whole truth behind Smoking Man but he may showing a picture of him as a
whole that, mosaic-like, proves true with what we already know.
It's worth remember the first time we
got a real look behind the curtain on Smoking Man was in an episode Morgan and
Wong themselves wrote: the classic One Breath. We see him in a barren
apartment, watching an old movie with an ashtray full of a butts and bear
bottles. That's pretty where we see the young Smoking Man in the second
flashback – the ashtrays already full, there's a radio blaring in an empty
apartment and he's pounding away at a typewriter. That's just as true when we
see him 23 years later.
Now remember what he said when Mulder
confronted him with a gun his face. "Look at me. No family. Some power.
I'm in the game because I believe what I'm doing is right. If people knew what
I knew, it would all fall apart." And if you watch Smoking Man from the
moment he's 'recruiting' until he's the boss from hell at Christmas to the
moment he's listening in on the meeting between Mulder and Scully, that's just
as true all the way through.
There's also the sense at the start
that he's never fully committed to it seriously. The moment Oswald is hauled
away as a patsy he lights up his first cigarette. As Monster of the Week points
out "Cigarettes are a great way to let God know you don't mind dying….We
never understand what he was before all this happened or what's driving him
now, beyond an abstract sense of duty." It makes us wonder why he allows
Mulder to continue his work. Does he think the X-Files are now contained or
maybe it's just another version of smoking, another slow route to his
inevitable death. (Which would make sense if the show could have just killed
him off, but you can't blame Morgan and Wong for that as they'd leave the show
for good after Season 4.)
And perhaps the most wonderful joke in
the entire episode is that he is the man creating history behind the scenes,
building an entire world – and for thirty years he's never been able to sell a
single one of his novels. This in itself is a deconstructionist idea of how
little power the writer's vision has when it comes to the idea of marketing –
something that eventually caused Darin to leave TV for good and which caused Space:
Above and Beyond to be cancelled bringing Glen and James Wong back into The
X-Files fold.
There's a spiritual truth that is very
central to this episode, not so much about the mythology but so much about
Smoking Man. We know he was friends with Bill Mulder as far back as Anasazi and
its been assumed, given the way Jeremiah Smith took the form of Deep Throat in
Talitha Cumi, that the two of them knew each other as well. There was a
flirtation during Season 3 with the idea that alien abductions were just cover
stories for experiments on humans and Smoking Man eludes to it by saying:
"That Roswell story we designed was gaining momentum. It had them all
looking in the wrong direction" and that the E.B.E. that showed up
couldn't have arrived a worse time. In E.B.E. Deep Throat said that he was one
of the three living men to kill an alien and that this is the reason he's
helping Mulder and in this episode we see him do just that. And the idea that
they've been wiretapping the X-Files offices is one that the show will come
back to quite a few times in the next few seasons; Mulder himself has long
assumed his apartment is being surveilled and no doubt suspects his office is
the same.
There's even a subtext that cuts to
the idea of so much of the best X-Files writer. Particularly when it comes to
the Monster Of The Week, there's always an idea that so many of the killers we
meet are just little men who want to be big and whose supernatural powers make
them just all the more ordinary. Vince Gilligan has already begun to lay a
foundation for it in his work and quite a few of the other staff writers
suggested. The theme of the banality of evil is a card The X-Files would
play incredibly well over its run and the idea of Smoking Man in this episode
fits into it. It's taken to an absurd level in the episode where he's refusing
to take Saddam Hussein's phone calls, wearing a nicotine bash and gives all of
his fellow conspirator identical ties for Christmas but it's actually a more
interesting idea then what the Syndicate has already become. And the comic
awkwardness about wanting to get this meeting over with because everyone wants
to get home for Christmas and how his younger associates try to ask him to come
out for a holiday party fits in very much with this – as is after he refusing
he goes right back home to the typewriter.
William B. Davis would later joke that
he saw his character as the hero of The X-Files and you could make an
argument that the Smoking Man might actually believe it. As 'Raul Bloodworth'
knows we are all the heroes of our stories and the CSM wants to see the world
as one. There's a sense of longing throughout the episode that we see both Davis
and Chris Owens (making the first of many complicated X-Files guest star
appearances in this episode) make clear throughout.
That's another part of the spiritual
truth.
Consider his speech just as Smoking
Man and Deep Throat gaze at the comatose alien:
How many historic moments have only
the two of us witnessed together? How often did we make or change history? And
our names can never grace any pages of record. No monument can bear our image.
And yet once again, tonight, the course of history will be set by two unknown
men – standing in the shadows.
That is likely why 'Raul Bloodworth'
does all his writing. He wants to have his name on something.
Consider how he speaks of Martin
Luther King when he makes that famous speech on April 4th 1967 and
listens with genuine regret. "I respect King," he tells the cabal.
"He's an extraordinary man." We know from the first sequence just
what the burden of being extraordinary entails. He truly regrets what has to be
done and insists on pulling the trigger himself. When he listens to RFK give
another famous speech and he mouths the words of Aeschylus along with Kennedy,
there's a similar acknowledgement of another 'extraordinary man' as well as the
way he finds the picture of the infant Fox Mulder at that moment. Perhaps he
has envy for Bill. A child is another way to make history.
And remember what Frohike says as what
is almost his final summation:
Henry David Thoreau wrote: "The
mass of men lead lives of quiet desperation.' His life has been anything but
quiet – yet I believe, nothing but desperate. He's the most dangerous man
alive. Not so much because he believes in his actions, but because he believes
those actions are all which life allows him. And yet, the only person that can
never escape him is himself.
I think that really does sum up
Smoking Man better than anything else we get on the series. It's almost
certainly more random then by design but as the series continues and the
conspiracy he's helped build for decades unravels due to forces beyond his control
we see that desperation play out time and again. He is as much a prisoner of
events as Mulder and Scully are.
So maybe that's why Raul Bloodworth is
so elated when he learns, after decades of struggle, he's finally managed to
get a story published. There's a comic gracefulness as he talks with his new
editor and talks about the cover and we see him type up his letter of
resignation and finally throws that pack of cigarettes in the trash. And then
he goes to the corner newsstand, finds his precious work of art has been cut to
ribbons in something close to a nudie magazine that even the owner thinks is
the bottom of the barrel. The way he says: "This isn't the ending that I
wrote! It's all wrong." Is delivered by a man who achieved his heart's
desire and now realizes he has to go back to his day job. Granted his day job
is controlling the world but still…
By the way that line of dialogue may
have been yet another in-joke. Apparently in the first draft when Frohike
finished CSM was supposed to take that rifle and assassinate our beloved Lone
Gunmen. However it was decided that the change in tone would have been far too
jarring and we get the end result where Smoking Man actually says the line of
his fictional character, lowering the gun.
I actually agree with Chris Carter who
talked him out of the idea. 'Musings' works best if you view it very much as
the pastiche that it is, something you're not supposed to take seriously. If
Smoking Man had killed Frohike at the end of it, it would have been wrong.
First the idea of the Lone Gunmen would have been permanently dismantled for
the rest of the series and that would have been bad for the series. Second and
more importantly it would have destroyed all of the belief that this was a
satire and the viewer would have been forced to consider that this was gospel
and that Frohike had been killed because he'd actually learned everything about
him. It would have turned what was a satire of the mythology into a
mythology episode and that would have ruined the whole point.
And last, it is the right ending. When
Smoking Man looks at Frohike and utters the catchphrase of Jack Colquitt – and
then chooses to lower his gun and give him 'the second chance' he does in his
novels, it's spiritually true to the whole idea of the episode. I actually once
theorized that the idea of Smoking Man being there is very much in Frohike's
head. The way he seems to anticipate everything that Frohike demands he do with
countermeasures and as a crowning touch has a lighter that reads 'Trust No One'
really does seem to be out of the images that everyone – including the viewer
has of him. Perhaps we're just reading the Raul Bloodworth version of the story
and we all know that's a myth.
Thirty years after 'Musings' first
aired I still don't know how much of it is true and how much is fiction. And
the thing is I don't need to know because I do believe its very true to what we
know about the villain and what we never know for sure. The Smoking Man is
iconic because he represents all that is wrong with the world, the puppet
master who pulls all the strings. Turns out he's just a slob like one of us
with an empty apartment, a crowded ashtray and who just fell into his career
because he couldn't realize his dream. I don't feel sympathy for this devil but
empathy, that I can manage. And that's a triumph on its own.