Tuesday, November 17, 2026

X-Files 30th Anniversary Episode Retrospective: Musings of A Cigarette Smoking Man

 

The first time I saw this episode 30 years ago I was like the vast majority of viewers: I genuinely believed everything we saw in this story was the complete, unfiltered truth about the Cigarette-Smoking Man. This astonished the author Glen Morgan (his first solo script while James Wong made his directorial debut) who had pretty much made it clear in the final minutes that none of it was canon.

Frohike says in the very last moments that: "So far, this is based only on a story I read in one of my weekly subscriptions that rang a few bells." In other words he found in a copy of Roman A Clef which was thrown in the trash and assumes that it is the fully story behind the Smoking Man.

It should be clear that there was confusion behind the scenes. Morgan and Chris Carter had many disagreements about which parts were true and William B. Davis was confused and frustrated by it. And if the behind the scenes people were baffled by which was true and what wasn't, one can hardly blame the viewer.

In truth I should have picked up on it because so much of what we see in this episode blatantly contradicts so much of what we've already seen in the mythology so far. The Smoking Man is apparently in his 20s in the first flashback in 1962 but we remember the flashback in Apocrypha where he and Bill Mulder were already hard at work covering up the conspiracy in 1953.  When Mulder confronted Smoking Man for the first time he told him: "I've watched Presidents die", not that he pulled the trigger himself. Reading so much of the talk of everyone, including the conversation between him and Deep Throat in Christmas of 1991, no one in the conspiracy knows anything about aliens and its all basically Cold War paranoia. And of course the idea that CSM is responsible for the Bills never winning the Super Bowl, rigging the Oscar nominations and the Olympics is the kind of conspiracy ridden drivel that you think not even Mulder believes.

The reason that Musings is one of the all-time masterpieces on The X-Files is because it basically pokes fun at the major idea behind the series itself, very much in the kind of deconstructionist way that Glen's brother Darin famously did during this tenure on the series. (Glen actually gives a blink and you miss it tribute to his brother by referring to him in a magazine story that has an article titled: "Where the Hell Is Darin Morgan?, a question many X-philes themselves were asking around this time.) The difference is one of nuance and how the comedy plays out. In all of Darin Morgan's script the deconstruction style was done with so many open jokes and parodies that the fourth wall was all but torn down. Glen's deconstruction, by contrast, barely draws attention to itself and is done more in a series of subtle nuances to things that don't refer to The X-Files but rather other films and TV shows.

The opening scene where a young Smoking Man is brought into meet with the military and is questioned on whether he was involved in the assassination of Lumbaba and Rafael Trujillo – political assassinations the CIA is long suspected in – is a direct pastiche one of the early scenes of Apocalypse Now. Oliver Stone's work is referenced, not just in the obvious parallel to JFK but films like Nixon and The Doors. So much of the references to aliens in such dismissive tone is clearly a dig at NBC's Dark Skies which was airing at the same time and took a historical look at so much what The X-Files was doing. And of course the Smoking Man's monologue is an incredible piss-take on Forest Gump which is honestly the funniest thing in the entire episode. (And I really wish Tom Hanks had said it now.)

There are even references to other actual spies. When Smoking Man meets with Lee Harvey Oswald, Oswald refers to him as "Mr. Hunt." This is clearly a reference to E. Howard Hunt, a former CIA agent best known for breaking into the Watergate Hotel as part of the Plumbers, has been linked in some circles to the Kennedy assassination and – wait for it! – wrote spy novels under a pseudonym. The scene where Smoking Man lectures Hoover for his failures to track Martin Luther King's leftward trajectory is very much involved with not just the wiretapping of the Civil Rights movement but the theory held by many that the FBI had King killed just like they did many of the Black Panthers. That Smoking Man is inserted in so many of these real life events – a la Forest Gump – doesn't detract from the very really possibility that there is more than a grain of truth to it.

Robert Shearman in his rave of this episode says that part of what makes it brilliant is that:

It sends up The X-Files' ability to find answers, suggesting that the entire spine of the backstory is never to be fully explained. That, in spite of the shows by-line, there is no truth out there. The whole point of The X-Files is ambiguity.

It promises to be a character study and it turns out to be anything but...because there is no character to study.

Fittingly I agree with some of this idea but not all of it. Morgan may not be pulling back the curtain to reveal the whole truth behind Smoking Man but he may showing a picture of him as a whole that, mosaic-like, proves true with what we already know.

It's worth remember the first time we got a real look behind the curtain on Smoking Man was in an episode Morgan and Wong themselves wrote: the classic One Breath. We see him in a barren apartment, watching an old movie with an ashtray full of a butts and bear bottles. That's pretty where we see the young Smoking Man in the second flashback – the ashtrays already full, there's a radio blaring in an empty apartment and he's pounding away at a typewriter. That's just as true when we see him 23 years later.

Now remember what he said when Mulder confronted him with a gun his face. "Look at me. No family. Some power. I'm in the game because I believe what I'm doing is right. If people knew what I knew, it would all fall apart." And if you watch Smoking Man from the moment he's 'recruiting' until he's the boss from hell at Christmas to the moment he's listening in on the meeting between Mulder and Scully, that's just as true all the way through.

There's also the sense at the start that he's never fully committed to it seriously. The moment Oswald is hauled away as a patsy he lights up his first cigarette. As Monster of the Week points out "Cigarettes are a great way to let God know you don't mind dying….We never understand what he was before all this happened or what's driving him now, beyond an abstract sense of duty." It makes us wonder why he allows Mulder to continue his work. Does he think the X-Files are now contained or maybe it's just another version of smoking, another slow route to his inevitable death. (Which would make sense if the show could have just killed him off, but you can't blame Morgan and Wong for that as they'd leave the show for good after Season 4.)

And perhaps the most wonderful joke in the entire episode is that he is the man creating history behind the scenes, building an entire world – and for thirty years he's never been able to sell a single one of his novels. This in itself is a deconstructionist idea of how little power the writer's vision has when it comes to the idea of marketing – something that eventually caused Darin to leave TV for good and which caused Space: Above and Beyond to be cancelled bringing Glen and James Wong back into The X-Files fold.

There's a spiritual truth that is very central to this episode, not so much about the mythology but so much about Smoking Man. We know he was friends with Bill Mulder as far back as Anasazi and its been assumed, given the way Jeremiah Smith took the form of Deep Throat in Talitha Cumi, that the two of them knew each other as well. There was a flirtation during Season 3 with the idea that alien abductions were just cover stories for experiments on humans and Smoking Man eludes to it by saying: "That Roswell story we designed was gaining momentum. It had them all looking in the wrong direction" and that the E.B.E. that showed up couldn't have arrived a worse time. In E.B.E. Deep Throat said that he was one of the three living men to kill an alien and that this is the reason he's helping Mulder and in this episode we see him do just that. And the idea that they've been wiretapping the X-Files offices is one that the show will come back to quite a few times in the next few seasons; Mulder himself has long assumed his apartment is being surveilled and no doubt suspects his office is the same.

There's even a subtext that cuts to the idea of so much of the best X-Files writer. Particularly when it comes to the Monster Of The Week, there's always an idea that so many of the killers we meet are just little men who want to be big and whose supernatural powers make them just all the more ordinary. Vince Gilligan has already begun to lay a foundation for it in his work and quite a few of the other staff writers suggested. The theme of the banality of evil is a card The X-Files would play incredibly well over its run and the idea of Smoking Man in this episode fits into it. It's taken to an absurd level in the episode where he's refusing to take Saddam Hussein's phone calls, wearing a nicotine bash and gives all of his fellow conspirator identical ties for Christmas but it's actually a more interesting idea then what the Syndicate has already become. And the comic awkwardness about wanting to get this meeting over with because everyone wants to get home for Christmas and how his younger associates try to ask him to come out for a holiday party fits in very much with this – as is after he refusing he goes right back home to the typewriter.

William B. Davis would later joke that he saw his character as the hero of The X-Files and you could make an argument that the Smoking Man might actually believe it. As 'Raul Bloodworth' knows we are all the heroes of our stories and the CSM wants to see the world as one. There's a sense of longing throughout the episode that we see both Davis and Chris Owens (making the first of many complicated X-Files guest star appearances in this episode) make clear throughout. 

That's another part of the spiritual truth.

Consider his speech just as Smoking Man and Deep Throat gaze at the comatose alien:

How many historic moments have only the two of us witnessed together? How often did we make or change history? And our names can never grace any pages of record. No monument can bear our image. And yet once again, tonight, the course of history will be set by two unknown men – standing in the shadows.

That is likely why 'Raul Bloodworth' does all his writing. He wants to have his name on something.

Consider how he speaks of Martin Luther King when he makes that famous speech on April 4th 1967 and listens with genuine regret. "I respect King," he tells the cabal. "He's an extraordinary man." We know from the first sequence just what the burden of being extraordinary entails. He truly regrets what has to be done and insists on pulling the trigger himself. When he listens to RFK give another famous speech and he mouths the words of Aeschylus along with Kennedy, there's a similar acknowledgement of another 'extraordinary man' as well as the way he finds the picture of the infant Fox Mulder at that moment. Perhaps he has envy for Bill. A child is another way to make history.

And remember what Frohike says as what is almost his final summation:

Henry David Thoreau wrote: "The mass of men lead lives of quiet desperation.' His life has been anything but quiet – yet I believe, nothing but desperate. He's the most dangerous man alive. Not so much because he believes in his actions, but because he believes those actions are all which life allows him. And yet, the only person that can never escape him is himself.

I think that really does sum up Smoking Man better than anything else we get on the series. It's almost certainly more random then by design but as the series continues and the conspiracy he's helped build for decades unravels due to forces beyond his control we see that desperation play out time and again. He is as much a prisoner of events as Mulder and Scully are.

So maybe that's why Raul Bloodworth is so elated when he learns, after decades of struggle, he's finally managed to get a story published. There's a comic gracefulness as he talks with his new editor and talks about the cover and we see him type up his letter of resignation and finally throws that pack of cigarettes in the trash. And then he goes to the corner newsstand, finds his precious work of art has been cut to ribbons in something close to a nudie magazine that even the owner thinks is the bottom of the barrel. The way he says: "This isn't the ending that I wrote! It's all wrong." Is delivered by a man who achieved his heart's desire and now realizes he has to go back to his day job. Granted his day job is controlling the world but still…

By the way that line of dialogue may have been yet another in-joke. Apparently in the first draft when Frohike finished CSM was supposed to take that rifle and assassinate our beloved Lone Gunmen. However it was decided that the change in tone would have been far too jarring and we get the end result where Smoking Man actually says the line of his fictional character, lowering the gun.

I actually agree with Chris Carter who talked him out of the idea. 'Musings' works best if you view it very much as the pastiche that it is, something you're not supposed to take seriously. If Smoking Man had killed Frohike at the end of it, it would have been wrong. First the idea of the Lone Gunmen would have been permanently dismantled for the rest of the series and that would have been bad for the series. Second and more importantly it would have destroyed all of the belief that this was a satire and the viewer would have been forced to consider that this was gospel and that Frohike had been killed because he'd actually learned everything about him. It would have turned what was a satire of the mythology into a mythology episode and that would have ruined the whole point.

And last, it is the right ending. When Smoking Man looks at Frohike and utters the catchphrase of Jack Colquitt – and then chooses to lower his gun and give him 'the second chance' he does in his novels, it's spiritually true to the whole idea of the episode. I actually once theorized that the idea of Smoking Man being there is very much in Frohike's head. The way he seems to anticipate everything that Frohike demands he do with countermeasures and as a crowning touch has a lighter that reads 'Trust No One' really does seem to be out of the images that everyone – including the viewer has of him. Perhaps we're just reading the Raul Bloodworth version of the story and we all know that's a myth.

Thirty years after 'Musings' first aired I still don't know how much of it is true and how much is fiction. And the thing is I don't need to know because I do believe its very true to what we know about the villain and what we never know for sure. The Smoking Man is iconic because he represents all that is wrong with the world, the puppet master who pulls all the strings. Turns out he's just a slob like one of us with an empty apartment, a crowded ashtray and who just fell into his career because he couldn't realize his dream. I don't feel sympathy for this devil but empathy, that I can manage. And that's a triumph on its own.

Mississippi and Michigan 2026: The Story of Two Historic Senators And Why The Less Likely Winner Represent Why The Left-Wing In America Will Always Fail (3000th Article)

 

 

Three years ago in a continuing series called 'The Right is Wrong and So's The Left I did a piece about the off-year gubernatorial elections, focusing on Kentucky and Mississippi and why I felt that both the Democratic Party and its left wing were paying inadequate attention to it. I went into detail about the history of Mississippi, in regards to both Jim Crow and Presidential politics, how the state was currently struggling with a horrible welfare scandal under its current governor Tate Reeves and how the Democratic candidate Brandon Presley had a genuine possibility of flipping the state. I also pointed out that Presley, like most candidates of either party in the Deep South, had made it clear he was pro-life and that even had he been pro-choice, given the nature of the Mississippi legislature which had a Republican supermajority in 2023 there was no way any governor could pass legislation on this issue without it being vetoes by the statehouse.

Then I quoted one particular Mississippi progressive who made it clear that while she wanted Presley to win she wasn't voting for him or at all:

“I want a better Mississippi. I do. But that better Mississippi includes all Mississippians. I don’t want a little piece anymore. I want my plate to be full…I’m tired of crumbs.”

I followed that up with:

Consider what this statement means in a larger context. Basically it argues that with some progressives, given a choice between having nothing or something, they’d rather have nothing. A crumb is not nothing. It might keep you alive a little longer, it might help some people survive. But if you only want a full plate and would rather have nothing instead of that, then it says a lot about who you are as a person.

Reeves would end up winning reelection by little more than 4 and a half percent that November in what was the closest statewide election in Mississippi since 1999. And I asked the question whether Presley could have won had the progressives been willing to hold their noses and vote for someone who didn't check all their ideological boxes but was still much better than a governor who had a four percent approval rating.

Even by November of 2023 the progressives were already in the midst of the obsession that has basically been the one thing driving them for the last three years: Gaza.  It has obsessed them to a level that almost all of their other major issues ever since the Bernie Sanders Presidential campaign coalesced into the modern progressive movement –  income inequality, campaign finance reform, universal health care, social justice – have for all intents and purposes been elbowed aside in favor of it.

It was seen in the student protest movements during much of 2024, the undecided primary vote during the Democratic primary in Michigan, how it cost Jamaal Bowman and Cori Bush their seats as they were primaried that summer, how it was a major factor in the DSA campaign that led to Zohran Mamdani's historical win in New York City. And it convinced a lot of people about how important the modern progressives were: people in the media, academics, Hollywood, cable news (who would view them either as sensation or pariah, depending on the network or commentator) and many people who were alarmed or overjoyed by their rhetoric. There was only one group of people who wasn't won over by this and it's the same group the left has always struggled with convincing: the American electorate.

This is where I really do think I deserve to take a victory lap when I pointed out repeatedly just how little power groups like the DSA and the Justice Democrats ever had at convincing anyone who wasn't in a deep-blue district in a blue state into their way of thinking. And I have to say I could never understand why so many educated people, particularly among the left, really thought that they could sway someone living in America that the most pressing issue of the day was what has happening in Gaza. None of these groups, for all their loudness and rancor on the subject, have ever found a coherent reason as to why when the top issue of today is affordability how what was happening in the Middle East was something that should be the sole reason they should vote. It didn't help matters that as the primary season swung into effect we were now in the middle of an undeclared war in Iran that was affecting prices of things such as gas and diesel oil that did affect millions of Americans far more than what was happening in Gaza. By the time of the last major Justice Democrat victory in the primaries the left, for once, seemed behind the curve when it came to what Americans cared about.

And it has to be noted that on what was a difficult Senate map for the Democrats none of the candidates running for office in deep red states were talking about Gaza at all.  I went through more than two dozen Peltola briefings before phone banking and Gaza never came up once nor did any of the voters I talked to in Alaska ever care that much. Iran, yes, Gaza no. Nor as far as I know were James Talarico and Sherrod Brown stumping on the subject and in none of the coverage of Senate debates in the general election, say in Iowa or Kansas, is there any record of candidates of either party discussing that subject. Debates were loud and contentious about many things and the stump speeches could be nasty but except for those on the far left no one was talking about Gaza or for that matter most of the subjects in the DSA and Justice Democrat platform.

The only places where the subject did come up were, as you might expect, those left-wing Democrats who were trying to win the nomination in the primary. Particularly in statewide races, they weren't having much luck. Graham Platner was the great hope for progressives in Maine but he would eventually and disastrously implode. (Let's let it go at that.) Francesca Hong, a democratic socialist, would eventually become the overwhelming favorite for the Wisconsin governor's race but on primary day she ended up narrowly losing to David Crowley, who then went on to trounce Tom Tiffany on election day. Angie Nixon did manage to exceed everyone's expectations in Florida both in the primary and the general but she spent most of the latter trying not to focus on being a DSA member.

So by autumn a lot of the forward momentum about the left-wing Democrats in statewide races was increasingly being stolen by the moderate wing of the party. The only major left-wing candidate running for a statewide race was Abdul El-Sayid in Michigan.

At this point I've written far too much about the man (including two articles on the eve of Election Day) so I'll just briefly restate the obvious. El-Sayed, more than any other Democrat in this election, seemed more interested in the people of Gaza then the people of Michigan. He made it clear while the primaries were still underway that, if he won, he was going to use his influence in Michigan to influence the Democratic nominee for President in 2028 particularly on Gaza. So much oxygen was focused on the civil war between the progressive and moderate wing of the party in Michigan that it struck me as odd that no one seemed willing to ask the candidate what he was going to do for the voters of his state if elected.

El-Sayed was expected to win in a landslide but instead barely eked out a victory over the more moderate Haley Stevens. Given just how narrow the margin was compared to the Democratic nominee for governor Jocelyn Benson, it was clear that El-Sayed was going to need to move to the center in order to win election in November.  That meant embracing a huge number of the people he'd pissed off, including the Jewish vote, African-Americans and everyone who voted for Stevens. El-Sayed made almost no effort to so during the general election. At no point did he seem interested in unifying the party behind him and gave lip service at best to building bridges to so many minority communities while refusing to denounce so much of the rhetoric of his strongest supporters. The rest of the party lined up behind him – they didn't want to lose in November – but El-Sayed ran a campaign that almost seemed to be daring the Democratic voters to vote for Mike Rogers.  To put it mildly he ran what was a primary style campaign in a general election and he seemed to be counting on the blue wave in his state and others to lift him to victory.

El-Sayid was like so many left-wing candidates: he relished all the media attention, whether it came from those who worshipped him or those who were repulsed by him. So it must have come as an incredible shock what happened on election night. After being the focus of so much attention for months by everybody almost every network and media consultant spent that entire night talking about how every other Democrat was doing in states much redder then his, winning in Senate, congressional, and gubernatorial races that Democrats hadn't managed to win in decades. By 11:30 PM the Democrats had taken control of the Senate so thoroughly that it was irrelevant if El-Sayed won or lost: they'd be in control of the Senate either way. And by the time most networks called his victory at three AM no one in the media system cared that much…because they were all looking at what was happening in Mississippi.

Now while I was paying some attention to what was happening in Mississippi in the last two years it had almost nothing to do with the Senate race. I mentioned way back in June 2025 how Joe Kennedy III, as part of the Third Way Committee, was spending much of his time in the Deep South not just in Mississippi, but also Alabama, Oklahoma and West Virginia trying to build a Democratic enclave in the Deep South. I was clear that I considered this a long-term project, likely not to see fruit until the end of the decade at best and that we'd get a chance to see how it went in the margins this cycle, particularly in the statewide races.

I mentioned it again in an article about five Senate races that were likely to go Republican but I would be watching anyway. One of them was about Scott Colom in Mississippi and two of the others were Annie Andrews and Adam Hamilton. I wrote that article in September. In the weeks that followed there was a lot of movement toward Andrews and Hamilton in the polls that increasingly made it seem likely that one, if not both states, were going to flip. I personally thought Hamilton was a sure thing on election night; Andrews was a tossup.

The reason that Scott Colom wasn't on my bingo card was that in the last three years, no one was doing any more polling in Mississippi for Senator then they were for governor. I counted maybe five or six polls during the entire cycle while we were getting new polls from Maine every day even before October. And while I got a lot of fundraising emails from candidates in the South such as Andrews and even Jamie Davis of Louisiana for months before the election, I didn't get one for Colom until the week before Election Day.

And I didn't even blame the Democrats for it. I had wanted them to expand the map and they'd done so beyond my wildest dreams well before September. But I also didn't want them to throw good money after bad.  And while I had far more faith in Senate and gubernatorial races that the vast majority of so many pundits, I wasn't going to extend it to states that were this small and deep red. I was just as skeptical, you should know, of polls I saw in Arkansas that saw the Senate and Governor races within striking distance of Democrats as well as some polls that argued independents such as Scott Bengs in South Dakota and Todd Achilles in Idaho were in striking distance, if not ahead, leading up to election day.  I wanted to believe them but I felt they were heavily skewed and as it turned out, they were and while the Republicans won by smaller margins than in the past, they still won handily in all of them.

I thought it was going to be closer then most thought, mainly because of the margin in the Governor's race three years earlier and that Cindy Hyde-Smith in her last run in 2020 ran well behind Trump winning by just over 9 points, a very small margin in a deep-red state. But going into election day I thought there was a better chance of Dan Osborn beating Pete Ricketts in Nebraska than Scott Colom did in Mississippi.

Well Osborn lost in Nebraska and Scott Colom made history in ways that put El-Sayed to shame. He is the first black Senator to win in Mississippi since Reconstruction and the first elected by popular vote. He is the first Democrat to win in the Senator since John Stennis in 1982 and while Stennis was not as overt a segregationist as his fellow Dixiecrats he was very much as racist. And he did in a state that gave 61 percent of its vote to Donald Trump just two years ago.

Now because victory has a thousand fathers every Democrat including quite a few progressives are trying to take credit for what happened. But while Colom is far more to the left of most Southern Democrats I have a hard time believing that he is a Bernie Sanders type candidate for multiple reasons.

First unlike Bernie himself, Colom had to rely on African-American votes to get him elected. This was, for the record, something that Abdul El-Sayed had a weakness in his primary victory where he got much of the white vote but trailed Haley Stevens in the African-American vote. (We'll have to wait until a deeper analysis in Michigan reveals the breakdown in the general.) In a state with the biggest African-American population in the country – nearly 34 percent – this was a necessity.

But African-Americans votes were never going to cut it alone. When the Democratic Party was successful in the original New South in the 1970s moderate Democrats managed to win by nearly sweeping the African-American vote while winning around a third of the white vote. I expressed reservations in several earlier articles that an African-American candidate could do as well in the south as a moderate white and argued that Roy Cooper and James Talarico had a better chance that candidates like Jamie Davis in Louisiana. (I didn't mention Colom because again I didn't think he had a chance.)

And the thing is Colom proved me wrong. According to polling data Colom managed to win roughly 25 percent of the white vote which is ten percent more than Kamala Harris did just two years ago and  twice as much as Obama got in 2012.  That may be the most astonishing thing about Colom's victory and there are a lot of astonishing things about it.

Then there's the biggest reason Colom will never be accepted as a progressive. He did the one thing that every left-wing academic, celebrity and many Democrats have been telling us that no serious person, much less a Democrat should ever do.

He went to Trump rallies. And talked to the people there as if they were human beings. He introduced himself and asked them what was important to them. He talked about the Second Amendment being important to them (that's another big strike) the high cost of gas and groceries, and how the Iran War was affecting them. None of them, for the record, acted the way we see them on the Daily Show or when they were interviewed in the Times. Which does make me wonder just how much everybody was picking and choosing to slant their stories.

But wait: he filmed these interactions and posted them on his campaign website. In other words he found common ground. How dare he!

In short he was doing the exact opposite of what the left's ideal candidate in this contest was doing. He was presenting himself as a unifier. He was talking to people who were not inclined to like him and might very well think of him in the same unflattering terms that many people do think of people like El-Sayid.

Part of this was no doubt out of political necessity for many reasons. The DNC by and large didn't give his campaign nearly enough money until the very end, something he has complained about in many of his interviews. He has also been very belligerent how so many political websites chose to de facto argue from day one that Mississippi was solid R as well as with so many other deep South states like Arkansas and Louisiana and therefore causing the party to ignore them. Which is a completely valid and rational response to have particularly given how the left-wing of the party in particular has always felt about that region.  

He had an impressive grass roots group of people behind him and a lot of active students – and really not much else.  Furthermore this has been a state by far most notorious for voter purges, has had one party rule for decades and is so understaff that as we've learned there are exactly 5 election officials in the entire state to handle so much of the voting, including absentee ballots as well as other issues.

And let's not forget Mississippi, in the 20th century alone,  is historic for having one of the most horrible Jim Crow histories even in the Deep South. This is the state where Emmett Till was lynched, where Medgar Ever was gunned down and his assassin got away with murder for 31 years and in the Freedom Summer of 1964 three civil rights workers were murdered in cold blood.  The state went for Strom Thurmond's Dixiecrat campaign in 1948, Harry Byrd's segregation campaign in 1960, gave 87 percent of its vote Barry Goldwater after he didn't sign the Civil Rights Bill of 1964 and went to Wallace in 1968.

Most of all I kept coming back to what I'd seen Mississippi progressives do three years ago when given a clear choice. If they'd rejected a far more electable candidate for governor in far more favorable conditions to that Democrat, what chance could Scott Colom have?

The answer was more than enough. And as a result Colom will join a history making freshman class of Democratic senators this cycle including El-Sayed. But I find it hard to believe that Colom will have much in common with the junior Senator from Michigan. He may be progressive for Mississippi but in states like Vermont and Massachusetts he might as well be a neoconservative. Given not just the narrowness of his victory but how reliably Republican this state is as senator he will not be gravitating to the kinds of causes that the left-wing of the party has. I suspect he will have more in common with Raphael Warnock of Georgia, who backed his campaign when no other Democrat would and knows just what it like to represent a deep South state, perhaps better than Jon Ossoff does.

He'll probably also gravitate not just to Cooper and Annie Andrews but the newly elected Adam Hamilton who has a similar attitude toward the pulpit, bully and otherwise that Colom has shown in his interviews. Like Andrews and James Talarico he is a young candidate in a deep red state that may be very much the future of Democratic politics going forward.

I also think he will have more influence in the new Senate then El-Sayed because is one of seven (and possibly eight) Democrats who've just won election in a state that has gone Republican at every level for decades. For all of the attractiveness of El-Sayed to many young people all he did was hold a seat that had been reliably Democrat. It's far more in the party's interest to keep seats that they just flipped and build on it going forward which makes both the campaign and kind of politics Colom represents more important to Congressional and national interests for the Democrats far more than the kind of playing to the base that El-Sayed has represented.

I'm a registered Democrat and I believe in many of its principle, including a big tent and a diverse range of viewpoints, including of those I might have disagreement with. I do think the tent should have room for both El-Sayed and Colom. However I also believe in party unity, building coalitions and a pecking order where we understand what plays in Michigan will not play in Mississippi. Those who follow the gospel on the former believe it should be one size fits all fifty states and anyone who deviates from that mindset might as well be a Republican. Those who follow the latter know can't afford that luxury and need to keep to win even those who might disagree with them immensely because if they vote Republican they will lose and lose badly.

 The Democratic Party has struggled nationally for much of the 21st century and the last decade in particular because it has leaned so far to the left nationally that the overwhelming majority of moderates and conservatives ended up going to the GOP. For a left that has leaned into an all or nothing approach and still seems to prefer nothing if they can't get all, it has led to a culture that in much of the last decade seemed to bring us on the verge of political irrelevance. This year's election helped us regain much of the center from the GOP at a nationwide level. If there's a choice for which road the Democratic Party should travel in the future I vote – and so did many other people, not just in Mississippi but nationwide – for the path of Scott Colom rather than Abdul El-Sayed. While I doubt the left will ever take that lesson it is imperative that Democrats do for the future not just of our party but perhaps America.

 

 

 

Monday, November 16, 2026

Theodore White on The Campaign Trail - Nelson Rockefeller, Part 2:Rockefeller and Goldwater in 1964 "Duel to the Death'

 

 

In his 1964 book White makes it clear that while no one could tell just how great the Republican disaster of that year would be the prospects were already dark in it he described what he considered the two differences between the two major parties – and like so much else he has written it is basically still true more than six decades later:

The Democrats believe in government – government as an instrument to do things…a party that guarantees to do things.

The Republicans' impossible dilemma is that they have never sorted out properly what it is that government should and should not do – and at what level…The Republicans largest client group, business, wants the government to do nothing – to leave it alone ; other client groups, chiefly inspired by the old Protestant ethic of individual salvation, feel morally the individual must be left the master of its own destiny. They campaign, generally, against government, the Democrats campaign, generally, for government.

Then in one of those quintessentially Theodore White lines he sums up the difference between the two parties:

The Republicans are for virtue, the Democrats for Santa Claus.

And ever since the New Deal had been created and well into the 1960s everyone believed in Santa Claus. It would be another twenty years before a Republican could sweep into power by arguing purely for virtue. But the difficulty was ever since the New Deal the Republican Party had been split between 'the Eastern establishment' and 'the primitives. The Eastern Establishment was essentially set in New York involving Wall Street and Madison Avenue. At the time it was the center of business and many of the major government allies in domestic and foreign policy should received their education there. And ever since 1940 it had basically dictated who would be the standard bearer for the Republican Party as President: Wendell Willkie in 1940, Thomas Dewey in 1944 and 1948, Eisenhower in 1952, Nixon in 1960. They had managed to keep the conservative wing in the Midwest, most notably Robert Taft away from the Presidential nomination.

This should have led to favorable conditions for Rockefeller, but they'd had no use for him in 1960. However since they had lost with Nixon in 1960 by such a narrow margin he still had popular momentum. But they were just as repulsed by Goldwater they knew they were headed for a collision course.

And Rockefeller had two major problems. The first problem, his moderation and his principles, the fact that he was too far to the left for where the party was at the time and where it was heading.  Still he might have been able to overcome it with the voters had it not been for the scandal that basically destroyed his run for the Presidency that year.

Considering the nature of politics in my lifetime where men can be accused of extramarital affairs and achieve the Presidency even before the 20th century was over Rockefeller's undoing is very much a product of his era. Rockefeller had divorced his first wife in November of 1961 and it didn't stop him from winning reelection to the governorship in a landslide. Nor was the problem that he remarried. It's how.

Margarita Murphy, who would soon become known to the world as 'Happy' had been part of the Rockefeller circle as far back as his father. She had married a scientist who worked in the Rockefeller institute. Her husband was insanely jealous of her and they'd undergone was passed for counseling in the 1960s.  She'd worked for Rockefeller's first campaign for governor and moved up in his circle.

White's sensibilities don't go into when the affair between the two began; it is clear it was going on at the time he chose to divorce his wife. The divorce followed was incredibly ugly and a spectacle for the New York press which was just as vitriolic and scandal ridden then as it is now.  Yet even that didn't prepare the people when Rockefeller announced that, in secret, he and Happy Murphy had married on May 4th 1963.

Almost immediately he was censured by many of his most loyal followers. Prescott Bush, the future father and grandfather of Presidents, branded him 'a destroyer of American homes'.  And for the next year the more conservative voters made it very clear what they thought with the sexism that was so typical of the time: "I ain't gonna to vote a woman to the White House who left her children." This would lead to Rockefeller being hung on the 'morality issue' which is bizarre because of how it was framed:

"Here were two marriages already actually broken, already destroyed and at an end. Here were two people in love. Should they marry publicly or have a clandestine love affair? A man of Rockefeller's wealth can have a love affair on any terms he wants. But he didn't want Happy that way. He wanted it open, she as his wife. He kept holding off hard delegate commitments until he could announce his remarriage – so that they could make up their minds with the facts on the table."

Rockefeller actually sounds noble when he told his advisers when they told him he would be putting his chances of nomination at risk and said, "He would not give up the woman he loved, even for the Presidency." Even given that the infidelities would end up continuing after his marriage there's something gallant about this, even if his faith in the public turned out to be horribly misguided.

Rockefeller's organization had gotten off to a good start throughout the spring of 1963 as White recounts going forward. But the moment his remarriage was announced his numbers plummeted. Prior to the remarriage he was the first choice of 43 percent of all Republicans polled, while Goldwater had just 26. In May Goldwater now had 35 percent, while Rockefeller had dropped to 30 percent. The following months showed no improvements with the Republican base. So it was clear when Rockefeller announced his candidacy the only hope he had was through the primaries.

On November 7th 1963 he announced his candidacy. Two weeks John F. Kennedy was assassinated. About ten days later White interviewed him and found him in a reflective mood:

The chances were slim. No one, he felt, would vote for him unless a national crisis forced him too. The new Mrs. Rockefeller did not want him to run for the Presidency; no one, in fact, wanted him to run except himself. If the people wanted him, they would take him.

Multiple people at the funeral, not just of Kennedy but one of his predecessors for governor Herbert Lehman had reacted positively to him.

The Kennedy assassination had shocked the country; Rockefeller thought it wanted leadership. But did it want him? Was this public turning to him or something deeper? And since it was obvious that the politicians did not want him, he must, as Kennedy had done, show them his muscle at the polls, in the primaries.

Indeed the politicians did not like him and they didn't like Goldwater either. But there weren't many obvious choices. Nixon was still possible, but he'd disastrously lost the California governor's race the previous year. George Romney, governor of Michigan, had no taste for it. Henry Cabot Lodge, Nixon's choice for Vice President was a possibility (more on him later) and some considered William Scranton, governor of Pennsylvania. All of their names would be on the ballots in many states but during this period none were active in the traditional sense.

So the Eastern establishment waited through the primaries to see the clash between Goldwater and Rockefeller which we see play out in the chapter White titles "Duel to the Death'. In the opening paragraph White tells us what we were going to see:

Presidential primaries are always savage. But the Presidential primaries of 1964 were to exceed in savagery and significance any other in modern politics….When the duel was over, the Republican Party was so desperately wounded that its leaders were fitter candidates for political hospitalization then political office.

There were seventeen primaries in 1964: sixteen plus Washington DC. White chooses to focus on the three he considers the most critical: New Hampshire on March 10th, Oregon on May 15th and California, the last one on June 2nd.

A brief recounting of what unfolded elsewhere is worth detailing. Despite not being an active candidate (I'll get to that below Lodge would prevail in New Jersey and Massachusetts. As favorite son Scranton won the Pennsylvania primary and 52 delegates. Rockefeller would win DC and West Virginia. Goldwater would win Texas, Indiana, Illinois and Nebraska while Margaret Chase Smith took the primary in her home state of Maine.

Well before the campaign as White details the Goldwater campaign had been hard at work getting delegates at a state level. They did enormously well in the South and would do so even as it became clear how damaged Goldwater was becoming as a candidate to the public.  But for all the work F. Clifton White and other members of the Goldwater campaign was doing they knew it would come to nothing if Goldwater couldn't notch at least one major primary win against Rockefeller, who they viewed as everything they despised. If they couldn't win at least one race then at the convention the party elders would have every reason to take everything they worked for away from them and they knew it. And indeed as the primary campaign went on their own candidate did much to argue for it.

It was clear in the primary from the start that the majority of those who attended Rockefeller rallies had come 'not because they loved Rockefeller, they were seeking an alternative to Goldwater." Because in those first three weeks of the campaign the story was Goldwater's candor which destroyed him. Briefly White sums up that by January 'he had shocked New Hampshire men into realizing there were several kinds of conservatives – and that he was not their kind."

A month before Kennedy's assassination he had suggested the use of atomic weaponry by NATO commanders; a week later he suggest the TVA be sold off. He'd already advocated withdrawal of recognition from the Soviet Union and abolition of the income tax. He said American missiles were undependable, that he wanted to make Social Security voluntary, called Eisenhower's administration a dime store New Deal. Goldwater was very much a victim of the press because of his candor and the first person it was a gift to was Rockefeller. Yet he was still too liberal for New Hampshire and they still were focused on his wife.

What happened in New Hampshire was unparalleled in politics before or since. A group of amateurs, led by a man who was an expert in direct mail, organized a write-in vote candidacy for Henry Cabot Lodge. It was done entirely without permission or even the presence of the candidate: Lodge was serving as Ambassador to Vietnam at the time and had in fact already endorsed Rockefeller before his departure. Yet this campaign received enormous support from those in that state who were desperate for an alternative.

And on March 10th Henry Cabot Lodge, who never set foot in New Hampshire, won the primary with 33,000 votes, 12,300 more than Goldwater. Rockefeller finished a distant third with 19,500. (Richard Nixon, also a write in candidate, received 15,600 votes.

White said that if the Lodge campaign hadn't happened he believed Rockefeller would have won by a flat majority, won by a bigger margin in Oregon and almost certainly beaten Goldwater in California. Instead Rockefeller knew he had no real chance of winning the nomination but now he had to run in order to make sure Goldwater was rejected,

Goldwater had been just as disheartened. He'd basically had no taste to run after Kennedy's assassination but had been talked into by Clifton White and his colleagues. "He'd relied on local advisers as inexperienced in Presidential politics as he was himself, and they had misled him." He made it clear he would skip campaigning in Oregon entirely, and concentrate entirely in California, even briefly considering dropping out.

The victory had made Lodge the choice of the rank and file among Republicans and by the time the first polls in Oregon came out he had 46 percent of the vote to Goldwater's 14 and Rockefeller's 13. (As a measure of just how low both men had fallen Nixon, still undeclared, was ahead of both men with 17 percent of the vote.

Yet during this campaign and particularly in Oregon Rockefeller found his voice. The newsmen respected his courage when he said: "I don't care any longer if I win – but I feel strongly about these things."

He made it clear he was for federal aid to schools, for Social Security and Medicare, that he wasn't a man who might set off war unwillingly. He was aided by John Lindsay's campaign manager who released him for this campaign and put up a direct mail effort that overmatched the Lodge campaign. There had been a civil war among Oregon Republicans between the extremists and liberals and in Portland, the machinery had been snatched by the former.

And as a result you could see the momentum shifting. On election night Rockefeller won decisively with 15,0000 more votes than Lodge. Goldwater had been completely humiliated, receiving just 50,000, only 2000 more than an organized write in for Nixon campaign got. And so, as White puts it "it was on to California for the final phase of the duel in the sun."

Conservative historians can be just as revisionist and biased about the past as their far left counterparts but when it comes to their political successes they can see with remarkable clarity. For that reason they know just how vital Goldwater's victory in the California primary was for the conservative movement, even if the fall election was a disaster.

White makes it very clear just how well Goldwater's team had organized in California for weeks in the leadup. He acknowledges just how organized they were throughout the state and just how much work they had to do to keep "the real kooks' from formal campaigning. It was extremely well organized from the bottom up.

The problem was the momentum seemed to shift from day to day as White made it clear. Prior to the Oregon primary Goldwater had a comfortable lead with 48 percent to Rockefeller's 39.  Immediately afterwards the momentum moved entire to Rockefeller who would lead anywhere from nine to eleven points in the polls. Rockefeller was barnstorming the state those last ten days. But as White reports:

But to counterbalance all this was the knowledge that the support Rockefeller had expected in California from other liberal Republicans – from Romney, from Scranton, from Nixon – had disappeared. If Rockefeller was indeed to win, as the polls now seemed to indicate, then the other Easterners felt it unnecessary to add to his margin by their support. Their attitude could be read simply: Let Rockefeller dispose of Goldwater in California, then we will finish off Rockefeller at the convention.

A century earlier the first Republican President famously said: "I don't confess to have control over events, but I confess they have control over me." Rockefeller knew this better than anyone: because Happy was pregnant with their first child who was due any day now.  Rockefeller was not flying back to New York every weekend; that would draw attention to the marital situation they wished to have ignored.

Rockefeller had bad timing in politics. In this case Happy gave birth to Nelson Junior on May 30th three days before the primary. Goldwater immediately seized on it as did his campaign. The effect in the polls was crystal clear; Rockefeller's advantage disappeared almost literally overnight. The day before the primary the two men were tied at 44 percent apiece with 12 percent still undecided.

The result was clear. Goldwater emerged the narrow winner with 51. 6 percent of the vote to Rockefeller's 48.4 percent. Rockefeller ended up carrying 43 of California's 47 countries but Goldwater won because of a 207,000 vote margin in Los Angeles and Orange County.

The power brokers behind the party instantly panicked. None of the liberal guard had done anything to support him during the campaign because they'd been sure he would defeat Goldwater and then they could move in and put up an alternative. But now Goldwater had beaten Rockefeller and the power brokers were suddenly aware of just how much work Clifton White and his colleagues had done building alliances over the last three years. They'd managed to lock up the South and the West but in order to win the Midwest those in power were only willing to sign on if Goldwater won in California. When he did, the nomination was all but locked up.

What followed was so disastrous in its planning and action as the Stop Goldwater movement tried desperately to stop a coup that had already happened. Rockefeller, however, chose to step aside. He knew he wasn't going to be President, bemoaned the disaster that was sure to happen in the fall and with a certain mix of wit, allowed himself to enjoy the spectacle. He would sit out the governor's conference in Cleveland that would become a spectacle that would end up being a farce.

It's possible that if Rockefeller had chosen to sit the convention at the Cow Palace out, he might well have ended up getting the Republican nomination four years later practically uncontested. He did attend as part of the platform committee and he was willing to try in a backhanded way to helped the doomed campaign for William Scranton to snatch the nomination from Goldwater.

However he was chosen to read and defend the first of three drafts to the minority report. This is how White describes the famous scene:

The slight ripple of normal applause as he rose was almost immediately drowned by a wave of boos, and then a billow of howling, and then by explosion. "We want Barry! We want Barry!" the galleries shouted.

His five minutes were allotted to the topic of extremism – and as with absolute zest in the first minute, he swung into his call, the audience exploded again. It was as if Rockefeller were poking with a long lance and prodding a den of hungry lions – they roared back at him. This was the face of the enemy – more important then columnists or switchblade hoodlums; this was the man who had savaged Barry from New Hampshire to California all through the spring. This was the man who called them kooks, and now, like kooks, they responded to prove his point.

White himself was in the galleries for Goldwater and eventually they became so loud that he, in the kindest of euphemisms, "uncomfortably left…for the safety of the floor." That was relatively quiet and he heard the speech:

"As Rockefeller, enjoying the spectacle and combat a lock of his full hair tumbling over his forehead taunted them (This is still a free country, ladies and gentlemen") they yelled even louder. "These things", called Rockefeller above the tumult, "have no place in America. But I can personally testify to their existence. And so can countless others who have also experienced anonymous midnight and early morning telephone calls, unsigned threatening letters, smear and hate literature, strong arm and goon tactics, bomb threats and bombings…infiltration and take-over of established political organizations by Communist and Nazi methods." They yelled back at him and strained in their seats as if trying to grab him and he shot back jauntily: "Some of you don't like to hear it, ladies and gentlemen, but it’s the truth."

The Goldwater men did everything they could to control the galleries anger that was being covered on TV from coast to coast. And what it showed was as White says:

"This was a new thing in American conventions – not a meeting, not a clash, but a coup d'etat." Goldwater was about to lead the nation to electoral disaster. And Rockefeller's campaign has essential provided LBJ with all the opposition research he could ever want for free.

The party basically chose to treat their standard bearer as if he smelled bad. Goldwater himself knew it was a doomed campaign. "If I had a pint of brains," Goldwater himself said after the election, "I should have known in San Francisco that I had won the nomination and lost the election right there. As it was, it wasn't until August that I knew it was hopeless." Goldwater's campaign will be the subject of its own article down the road. For now, all you need to know is that when Goldwater came to New York "the Rockefeller troops ignored Goldwater as if he were spoiled refuse and concentrating on reelecting Senator Kenneth Keating, who openly disassociated himself from the national ticket. Keating would run 860,500 votes ahead of Goldwater in New York – LBJ got 68.6 percent of the popular vote there- and yet he would still lose to Robert F. Kennedy by nearly 700,000 votes."

And that as a reminder was a decent performance by Goldwater in 1964. LBJ would win in a landslide with 61 percent of the popular vote and a margin of 16 million over Goldwater. He would carry 44 states and the District of Columbia with 486 electoral votes. Goldwater had carried only six states: his home state of Arizona and five Southern states, the most progress a Republican had made in that region since Reconstruction. As White put it in the final chapter: "The elections of 1964 had left the Republican Party in desperate condition…The Republican Party requires a strategy; and no one yet has persuaded the party of a strategy that can move it."

Outside events, of course, would give them a strategy. But no one knew it at the time.

In the final part of this series I will deal with how Rockefeller approached 1968 and how he may have come the closest in his three bids for the Presidency to getting the nomination – and still missed.

Sunday, November 15, 2026

How Did Justice Democrats Do This Cycle Compared To Those They Primaried Last Time? And Other Proof The Time for Reckoning With Progressive Electoral Failures Has Become Clear

 

In early August after both Abdul El-Sayid and Francesca Hong both underperformed incredibly in primaries in both the Michigan senatorial and Wisconsin gubernatorial primaries respectively The New York Times published an article asking: "Do Left-Wing Candidates Underperform?" One of the most in-depth looks to date by a mainstream and honestly fairly liberal publication at the far left, it make a convincing argument that indeed many DSA candidates, Justice Democrats and even senators such as Elizabeth Warren did poorly in their general elections compared to more centrist candidates.

It was part of increased scrutiny that many publications which, after essentially give the far left-wing of the party a free pass for pretty much a decade, were now asking questions that I have had about them for the last two years and that the Democratic Party has been dealing with ever since Bernie Sanders' primary campaign did much to cause divisions in the party that in ten years had not fully healed. They'd begun in earnest after Graham Platner's campaign for the Senate had spectacularly imploded long after so many warning signs had been shouted from even some Democrats, had gotten louder after Zohran Mamdani had used much of his political capital in New York to primary two left-wing Democrats with DSA members and reached their crescendo in the aftermath of the Michigan Senate primary.

I was merely grateful that the discussion was being had, simply because I'd been making a similar argument with the Justice Democrats for years. Indeed roughly a month before the Times article was published I'd made a similar argument asking whether Justice Democrats, after being able to primary an incumbent had a history of underperforming in the general election? I'd found four case studies of such an event and found that in three of them – Marie Newman, Jamaal Bowman and Cori Bush all in 2020 – that they had in fact underperformed compared to their immediate predecessors. Furthermore within two more cycles all three candidates would themselves have been primaried from their right and lost their seats.

The early evidence was very promising. But I didn't think it on its own enough to tell the tale. Then after the 2026 primaries six members of the Justice Democrats managed to primary incumbents and move on to the general. With a much bigger sample size to look at I think it is worth considering how exactly this played out.

I should say given how many Trump districts were flipped during the Blue Wave as well as how many red states elected Democratic senators and governors this cycle there is every reason to consider this more academic. However it is important to make the statistical record known since no less a journal then The Atlantic published online about how the left was engaging in its own form of election denialism. I'll deal with their parts of that when I'm finished here to give the full portrait. I also think it's worth looking to see how some of those did compared to those who held the district two years earlier because these were also very progressive candidates in deep blue districts. This gives us three more choices to look at.

So with that in mind let's look at the record. Keep in mind that there were also four other  Justice Democrats who ran in primaries this cycle and all of them lost their challenges. I'll get to that below as well.

 

 

Mai Vang, California 7th 2026 Lost to Doris Matsui with 47.58 percent of the vote.

Doris Matsui in 2024 – 66.8 percent to Tom Silva's 33.2 percent.

This election, like both California elections is an outlier, because in 2024 Matsui had to face a Republican opponent and in this case she faced a Democrat. Nevertheless the fact remains Vang managed to win the primary and still lost the general to the incumbent.

 

Angela Gonzales-Torres, California 34th   2026 62. 19 percent to Jimmy Gomez's 37.8 percent of the vote

Jimmy Gomez 2024 defeated Jimmy Kim 56 percent to 44.4 percent

In this election Gomez was facing against a Democrat both times. However it should be noting despite winning by a much bigger margin she still only got a little more than 3000 votes in the general election that Gomez did in winning two years ago

 

Melat Kiros, Colorado 1st  2026 – 78,36 percent of the vote with 239,082 votes

Diana DeGette 2024 – 76.5 percent of the vote with 264,606 votes

Kiros won with a far bigger margin over her combined opponents winning percentage. However she received 25,5024 few votes in her victory. Considering that in the aftermath of this election three Colorado House districts flipped this is telling.

 

Donavan McKinney, Michigan 13th  2026 – 76.1 percent of the vote

Shri Vanedar (2024) – 76.5 percent of the vote with 209,882 votes total.

McKinney already has as many votes and Vanedar but at this point only 69 percent of the votes are tallied. It's likely he'll exceed Vanedar's final total but the percentage will be lower.

 

Adam Hamawy New Jersey 12th 2026 – 70.62 percent with 168,447 votes cast

Bonnie Watson Coleman 2024 – 61. 6 percent with 196,871 votes cast for the candidate

Again we see the same pattern. Hamawy got a bigger percent but he finished with nearly 24,500 votes less than Coleman did 2 years earlier.

 

 

Claire Valdez, New York 7th  (WON) – 83 percent, 135,179 votes.

Nydia Velasquez (2024) – 77.9 percent of the vote, 172,795 votes cast.

Again Valdez got a bigger percentage of the vote overall but finished over 37, 616 votes behind Velasquez two years ago.

 

Darializa Avila Chevalier, New York 13th (WON) – 87 percent of the vote, 141,014

Adriano Espaillat (2024) – 83 percent of the vote 181,800 votes cast.

This is by far the biggest underperformance yet with Chevalier getting over 40,000 votes less than Espaillat two years earlier.

 

As a reminder this election was one of the biggest landslides for Democrats in over half a century, which has left many pundits gasping to try and come up with terms to describe it. And yet somehow almost across the board every single Justice Democrat drastically underperformed in some of the bluest districts in the country.

And to be clear in every state they were on the ballot in it there were conditions that should have lifted them to victory. In California there had been a redrawn map to heavily favor Democrats and yet only one Justice Democrat won. Three heavily Republican districts in Colorado were flipped, as were one in New Jersey and one in Michigan. Every swing district Democrat running for office won and quite a few upstate Democrats overperformed.  The voters turned out in massive numbers for everybody except by any standard the Justice Democrats.

This is before you factor in the four other primaries that Justice Democrats lost, in North Carolina, California and two in Illinois. The Blue Wave, remember, was so big that the Congressional caucus for North Carolina may be majority Democrat for the first time in decades. The wave was big enough to lift Justin Pearson to within contention in the redrawn Tennessee 9th but he still couldn't pull it off and it was a loss, nonetheless.

And as The Atlantic reported across the country in every red state where the Democrat won a senate or governor's race they all vastly overperformed Kamala Harris  did on the ballot 2 years ago. Harris was by far the more left-wing candidate in the race on issues such on the rights of transgenders. Josh Turek and Adam Hamilton took far more moderate positions then she did and they managed to flip their seats in Iowa and Kansas. Amy Acton took a far more aggressive position on it that was nearly conservative and now she's the new governor of Ohio. The only Senate candidate who ran on a similar platform to Harris was Troy Jackson in Maine – and he actually underperformed in that state compared to her.

Nor was it only in electing candidates where the left underperformed. As was reported in a reliable source in Washington and Colorado, both very blue states, there were ballot initiatives that sought to ban trans women and girls from competing in women's sports. It passed in both states with the initiative In Washington getting 56 percent of the vote in a state Harris got 57 percent in two years ago and 52 percent of the vote in Colorado which Harris won with 54 percent of the vote. Existing restrictions were expanded in Arizona and codified into the state constitution Nebraska.

And lest you think that this was all about bigotry (as the left on this site has made it absolutely clear it was) there was also a one time billionaire tax based on their net worth. Prop 40 failed with 52.8 percent of the voters rejecting it. This is one of the bluest states in the nation with would argue, as with the two props above, that the opposition these prominent position to the Justice Democrats have significant bipartisan support.

And yet there is no sign that any progressives, both in Congress or in the virtual ether, are capable of reading the room. When articles like this were published online, almost every major comment chose to either engage in their boilerplate argument that these positions were the correct ones or that the author was a bigot. The results of the election gives vote counts and results that are clear to anyone who can look at them – and yet somehow the left is engaged in a worse form of election denial then MAGA is.

I find that part the most striking. In the past week after Trump went through his usual rigmarole about the election being rigged he got no support from either any Congressional Republicans or even the media. Megan Kelly, when she heard what he said, posted on Twitter "just stop." Republican media is engaged in recriminations and a majority of the die-hard MAGA movement now says that Trump has less power after the midterms then before. They don't like the reality they live in, but they've accepted it and our trying to rebuild.

By contrast the left-wing of the Democratic Party is facing statistical insignificance in a way they just haven't in the past decade. The reactions of Bernie Sanders, arguing that the election was a mandate for progressive values, didn't land with the same force and many in the media are beginning to wonder if he's as out of touch with reality as the President. His decision to back Chris Van Hollen of Maryland for majority leader would seem like a bid for relevance were it not for the fact that most insiders agree that this is an exercise in vanity. No one expects Van Hollen to win: he's expected to get at most 12 to 15 votes. And with so many victories in deep red districts and red states the Democratic Party has the opportunity to build the kinds of majorities not seen since the height of FDR's first term in the next cycle. If that happens the left's role in the Party will become almost irrelevant when it comes to policy and the direction of America.

In the aftermath of the 2016 election the left wing of America as a whole has had more influence over the political discussion then they have in decades, even while that has led to little in terms of policy accomplishments or elected officials. Because Donald Trump was the dominant figure in American politics at the time they managed to avoid the kind of in-depth analysis of their policies and positions that he was getting as the focus. Now with him approaching lame duck status the magnifying glass is being put on them from the very organizations that held them in esteem for so long and the margins and numbers for Democrats are so big that mathematically they may never be this close to power again. The people have spoken in the loudest way possible and they still don't like what they have to say. The good news is the record shows far better where they stand in the electorate's thinking and they'll understand it, even if the left refuses to.