Thursday, March 27, 2025

2025 Emmy Watch Phase 2, Part 1: What The UK TV Nominations Might Tell Us About The Emmy Nominations

 

 

Phase One of the Awards that can potentially give insight into this year’s Emmys ended in late February with the SAG Awards. We now begin Phase 2 which I have usually used smaller critics groups to parse the idea.

In the recent past I have tried to rely on more American based shows such as the MTV TV & Movie Awards and the People’s Choice Awards. But the former never aired last year and the latter has yet to schedule any nominations at all. (It’s conceivable the recent wildfires in LA may well have had a similar effect.) So I’m going to go to a somewhat unlikely place to try and comprehend America TV: England.

BAFTA has been giving television nominations along with movies and anyone who has watched Peak TV knows the overlap between the two over the past decade. Most of is related to streaming services such as Netflix’s relationship with The Crown and Bridgerton and Apple TV’s recent extraordinary series Slow Horses. There has also often been an overlap between the limited series of Peak TV and combined with both the number of British performers in American series as well as the International Award there are possibilities for insight into what the Emmys may do in just over three months.

So with that in mind let’s take a look at the BAFTA nominations for television which were revealed earlier today.

LEADING ACTRESS

Several of the series mentioned were contenders for last year such as Mr. Bates Vs. The Post Office. However two nominees do suggest a possibility: Lola Petticrew for the FX/Hulu limited series Say Nothing which as we shall see is on the short list of Emmy nominations for limited series and Marisa Abela for her work on the underrated HBO drama Industry. The latter was nominated for Best Drama by the Critics Choice Awards this past December. While it has a slight chance for nominations, considering that such powerhouses as The White Lotus and The Last Of Us will no doubt dominate the Emmy nominations, it is highly unlikely.

LEADING ACTOR

Richard Gadd, unsurprisingly, is nominated in this category for Baby Reindeer and Gary Oldman is here for Slow Horses. It is likely one or the other will triumph.

There are some interesting side notes. David Tennant has been nominated in this category for Rivals a series which has become a critical hit on Hulu and Martin Freeman has been nominated for his work in the BBC one series The Responder.

 

SUPPORTING ACTOR

Here are three genuine possibilities for nominations. Jonathan Pryce and Christopher Chung have been nominated for their work in Slow Horses. (Jack Lowden isn’t here, which is odd considering that he has already been nominated by the Golden Globes.) Damian Lewis has been nominated for the most recent installment in Wolf Hall and given that series popularity in connection with Masterpiece Theater, he may be a dark horse for a nomination. Lewis, of course, has been part of many American dramas and has received nominations for A Spy Among Friends just two years ago.

 

SUPPORTING ACTRESS.

Little surprise to see Jessica Gunning and Nava Mau nominated for Baby Reindeer as Gunning has dominated the awards circuit this past year and Mau has won more than her share. Maxine Peake is nominating for Say Nothing, which may well work in her favor. None of the others are likely contenders.

 

FEMALE PERFORMANCE INA  COMEDY

None that are likely to contend though there are some interesting nominees. Anjana Vasan is nominated for the cult sensation We are Lady Parts. Nicola Coughlan, who is known for her work on Bridgerton is nominated for the show Big Mood and Lolly Adefope was nominated for the now cancelled HBO/Sky collaboration The Franchise.

 

MALE PERFORMANCE IN A COMEDY

The only series I recognize is the failed Netflix mythology comedy Kaos for which Nabhaan Rizwan is nominated.

 

DRAMA SERIES

Wolf Hall: The Mirror in the Light will like contend for Best Limited Series and fans of Supacell will be glad to see it here.

 

LIMITED DRAMA

Both of the major contenders were from last year: Baby Reindeer and Mr. Bates Vs. The Post Office. Fans of One Day will be intrigued to see it here.

 

Those who are fans of reality TV will be pleased to see The Traitors n contention in that category. And considering it did with the Emmy for Best Reality show this past year I guess BAFTA acknowledges reality to.

 

International

Two of the contenders are among the bigger nominees from last year: Shogun and Night Country. Say Nothing is nominated for International which would seem to give a slight push for its chances. If you’re a fan of Colin From Accounts it’s here as well.

 

Bridgerton fans will be glad to see that ‘THE’ carriage scene where Colin admits his feelings for Penelope is among the contenders for Memorable Moment. Three of the other contenders are fictional – including Mr. Bates Vs. The Post Office and Rivals and two others are non-fictional. You’d think they’d have something for Donny’s breakdown onstage in Baby Reindeer but it has gotten more than its share of nominations.

I’ll now deal with some of the craft nominations.

Directing has contenders from Baby Reindeer, We Are Lady Parts and Wolf Hall. Writing in comedy has a nomination for Brett Goldstein for his work for Shrinking and a writing nomination for We Are Lady Parts. Drama nominates Mr. Bates, Baby Reindeer – and Industry.

As for technical nominations as you might expect House of The Dragon has more than its share of these and I am pleased to see nominations for Day of The Jackal and Masters of The Air. (I’m actually kind of surprising the former isn’t up for more awards considering its popularity across the pond. Maybe the BBC can’t find Peacock either.)

There are many nominations for Slow Horses, Rivals and Shogun among the technical nominations, a couple for Black Doves (which also didn’t have much of an imprint with BAFTA) There are a few nominations for quiet sensations like Mary & George and Sweetpea. (I guess they can find Starz.)

Overall Slow Horses and Rivals have the most nominations apiece with 6 while Say Nothing finished with four and Industry managed to get three. Considering how many British actors are in House of the Dragon its striking it walked away with only technical nominations. Then again this is a series that tends to honor only British Actors and creative forces. The rest of the UK – well, there are some other awards shows and I may follow up on that later on.

Clearly the series that are most benefited by this are Slow Horses and Say Nothing. In a perfect world Industry which is a better series than House of The Dragon and far more of a contender for Best Drama then White Lotus would earn a nomination for Best Drama from the Emmys. But since when have the Emmys ever gone for merit when it comes to HBO? (In an unrelated subject take as much time filming Season 3 of Euphoria as you need.) Wolf Hall remains a dark horse in the Emmy race down the road but we’ll have to wait and see. I’ve been meaning to look at the current season of Horses soon and now I have an imperative to get to Say Nothing which was already contending for casting and WGA awards.

Irish Film and Television have their nominations and since I’m already there…

Bad Sisters got a whopping six nominations: Best Drama, Best Director, Best Actress for Sharon Horgan, Best Supporting Actor for Michale Smiley,  Best Supporting Actress nods for Fiona Shaw and Eve Hewson. Shaw was nominated by the Critics Choice Awards and Horgan was nominated for Best Actress in 2023 by the Emmys.

And as you’d expect for a series that had to do with the Troubles Say Nothing was dominant with nominations in every major category. Lola Petticrew was nominated here as she was at BAFTA but rather than nominate Maxine Peake for Supporting Actress, Hazel Doupe was nominated ins stead. How ironic of all the performers nominated it is more likely the American in the cast Elisabeth Moss is the most likely nominee

Over all the Irish TV Awards seem more likely to have contenders among the Emmys that the BAFTAs will. Day of the Jackal is nominated for Directing and Writing, Colin Farrell is up for Lead Actor in a Drama and he contends against Andrew Scott for Ripley. Michael Fassbender is also present for his work in the Showtime Drama The Agency. Anthony Boyle is nominated both for Say Nothing and his work in Masters of the Air. Nicola Coughlan was nominated for Best Actress for Bridgerton. Even 3-Body Problem has a contender in Liam Cunningham for Supporting Actor.

The Penguin has nominations for cinematography and House of The Dragon has been nominated for Costumes. 3 Body Problem is up for Editing and strangely enough Shogun for Visual Effects. (The Crafts Awards don’t differentiate between film and television, no doubt more fixed on the Best work of Irish people working in the industry, which is why the editors for Bad Sisters and Say Nothing are contending against Paddington in Peru.) For the record they got a casting award creating and the Oscars are still a few years away.

Bad Sisters was a contender for many Emmys for its first season and may very well contend again. Day of the Jackal has been nominated for the majority of the Best Drama awards so far and this would seem to boost its prominence. Will the nominations from Britain and Ireland combined with its American footprint be enough to push Say Nothing into what is basically a wide open Emmy race for nominations in the limited series category? We will see.

I’ll be back some time in April when I have news on the Peabodys and the TCA the next part of Phase Two.

No comments:

Post a Comment