Tuesday, January 27, 2026

Emmy Watch 2026 Phase One Concluded: Reports on The Nominations for the Critical Guild Awards For 2025

 

 

Today marks for me the official end of Phase One of Emmy Watch 2026 as this morning the WGA announced its official end of year nominations for the year just past in almost every major category.

Every major contributor to the artistic process has end of year nominations but for the purposes of these articles I've decided to focus on the four major ones. Earlier this month I covered the SAG nominations for television and in this article I will look at the nominations for the Writers Guild, the Directors Guild and the Producers Guild.

Because these guilds cover the entire year just past and because the Emmys remains different than that of films historically these groups have a tendency to give their major prizes for shows that may have aired for the previous season then the one to come. There are exceptions in the individual awards rather than the overall ones but because of this truth I'll be focusing more on the nominations for every group then the actual awards.

So let's take a look at the nominees. We'll start with the PGA which were announced on December 9th 2026.

 

OUTSTANDING PRODUCER OF TV DRAMA

Few surprises. Four of the nominees were nominated for this past year: Andor, The Pitt, Severance and The White Lotus. The other two are Season 3 of The Diplomat and Pluribus both of which are expected to contend.

 

OUTSTANDING PRODUCER OF EPISODIC TELEVISION

The Studio and Hacks represent the past season. Season 4 of The Bear and Season 5 of Only Murders in the Building will be eligible this next year. Despite the absence of its nominations from the Critics Choice Awards The Bear will likely contend.

The biggest surprise is South Park being included. South Park will technically be eligible to compete in the comedy awards but there are different eligibility requirements for the Emmys.

 

OUTSTANDING PRODUCER FOR A LIMITED SERIES/ANTHOLOGY

Adolescence, Dying for Sex and the current season of Black Mirror are all holdovers from last season. The Beast in Me continues to contend. We also see the presence of the Netflix Limited Series Black Rabbit which has received acting nominations from the Golden Globes and SAG awards.

I'll forego the remainder of the nominees because few involve fictional television. That said I'm glad to see Jeopardy contending for Best Game Show.

 

Now on to the Directors Guild nominations. The nominees were announced on January 7th. It's worth remembering in television, individual achievements in direction are noting rather than overall series.

 

Direction for a Drama Series

The Pitt is nominated both for the Pilot and the 6 PM episode. Severance has a nomination for Ben Stiller for the Season 2 finale. Andor was nominated for 'Who are You?"

Liza Johnson was nominated for directing the 'Amagansett' episode of The Diplomat which will contender this year.

 

Direction for Comedy Series

Note to the Emmys. The Directors Guild considers White Lotus a comedy and The Bear a comedy.  Keep the former in mind.

Mike White was nominated for an individual episode but considering her writes the entire series that's superfluous. Seth Rogen and Evan Goldberg were nominated for directing 'The Oner' episode of The Studio. Lucia Aniello was nominated for directing 'The Slippery Slope' episode of Hacks.

Christopher Storer and Janciza Bravo were nominated for directing The Bear.

 

LIMITED AND ANTHOLOGY SERIES

In what I suspect will be the biggest shock Adolescence was not nominated for directing. Let's see what is.

The series finale of Dying for Sex and the 'Common People' episode of Black Mirror were nominated. So was Lesli Linka Glatter for Zero Day (he was also nominated by the Emmys) Jason Bateman was nominated for directing 'The Black Rabbits' episode of Black Rabbit and Antonio Campos was nominated for directed the 'Sick Puppy' episode of The Beast in Me. Increasingly it looks like two series will be contending for Emmys down the road.

 

Props to Jeopardy to getting a nomination for direction. And is that the real Adam Sandler nominated for directing The Price is Right ? No, it's someone with the same name.

Finally here are the nominations for the WGA which were announced today

 

TELEVISION DRAMA

Hmm. The WGA considers The White Lotus a drama while the DGA considers a comedy.

The other four nominees are Andor, The Pitt, Pluribus and Severance.

 

COMEDY SERIES

Now The Bear is nominated at all. The Studio and Hacks are here for the previous season: Abbott Elementary covers this year and last. The Rehearsal covers last year.

The new face: HBO's The Chair Company. And the WGA likes it because…

 

NEW SERIES

Here's The Chair Company again. This one might actually be the most helpful.

The Studio and The Pitt are here as well as well as Pluribus. But we also see a face familiar from the Golden Globes and Critics Choice nominees: Task.

 

LIMITED SERIES

Adolescence isn't here either.  Looks like the Guild Awards have a different opinion of it than almost everyone else. I'm beginning to like them more.

They've nominated Sirens in its place which I find admirable and I expected to see Dying for Sex here. Black Rabbit and The Beast in Me have cemented themselves as contenders and we also see the presence of Death By Lightning which the Critics recognized but no other group did.

 

Now on to individual episodes.

Episodic Drama:

The pilot episode of The Pitt is the only familiar face. We do have two holdovers from last year though neither was recognized for anything: Forever and The Handmaid's Tale.

We have the 'Got Milk' and 'Charm Offensive' nominees of Pluribus and here is 'A Still Small Voice' for Task. Task and Pluribus are now officially major contenders for Emmys this fall in case there was any doubt.

 

Episodic Comedy

This is an interesting group. We have the pilot episode of The Studio and we also have an episode of The Rehearsal. We have the 'Worms' episode of The Bear for next year. It's the other nominees I find intriguing.

We have the Prelude episode of The Righteous Gemstones which famously told us showed how Bradley Cooper founding the Gemstone line. We have 'A Call From God' from Mo which hasn't really contended for much. And we have 'The Sleazy Georgian' from the canceled Poker Face. So we're basically honoring the past but shows that were overlooked unjustly by most awards shows.

 

In my opinion the biggest surprise is that for all the acclaim that so many people gave to Adolescence and the fact that it is the winner for Best Directing and Writing by the Emmys last year, the respective guilds didn't even nominate the show. It's likely this is because they consider Adolescence a British series and these are the Writers and Directors Guild of America. Shows like Slow Horses have faced the same obstacles from these guilds in the past and the SAG awards have been more forgiving.

On the plus side it does give us a chance to see which limited series may contend. The Ed Gein story continues to be shut out but more troubling is the complete shutout of All Her Fault by all three guilds.  It can't be laid at the feet of solely being on a service like Peacock; they had no problem recognizing Poker Face at the WGA and numerous other programs in non-fiction from it were nominated by all three guilds.

The most clarity we have so far for the coming year is in Best Limited Series category. The Beast in Me now seems like a lock to contend in every major category and Black Rabbit is moving up rapidly. And its worth noting it is increasingly unlikely Season 2 of The Studio will be released in time for the 2026 Emmy nominations.

The picture of the Emmy nominations for 2026 is still fuzzy but its beginning to clarify at the official end of Phase One. My next report will come when I deal with the NAACP Image nominations for TV which came out earlier this month. Stay tuned.

No comments:

Post a Comment