Well, I’ve taken
a day to try and get my head around the nominations in the Drama Series, and it
still doesn’t compute. You expected the Emmys to share the wealth now that the
behemoth of Game of Thrones is gone
forever, but there just seems to be so little real logic to it, particularly in
the acting nominations.
In my opinion,
the biggest victim is Better Call Saul. For
years, they’ve been nominated in the acting categories and ignoring it in
writing and directing. This year, they went the other way. How can you nominate
the series without nominating Bob Odenkirk –it’s like nominating breaking Bad and ignoring Bryan Cranston.
And everyone was certain this would be the year that Jonathan Banks would
finally win – and he isn’t even nominated. Seriously, eight nominees in each of the supporting categories and
you can’t find room for either Banks or Rhea Seehorn.
And I’ll be
honest. I expected Ozark to get
nominated – it is a good show. But eighteen nominations? Couldn’t they give some of the writing nominations to This is Us or Big
Little Lies? Indeed, there seems to be an overcorrection toward the
technical rather than the others.
Now I’ll go into
detail.
OUTSTANDING DRAMA SERIES
Better Call Saul, The Crown, Succession and
Stranger Things all deserve to be
here. I can see the logic for Ozark and
Killing Eve. But what is with the
obsession with The Handmaid’s Tale, which
even it’s most devoted fans thought had faltered badly in Season 3?
And where the
hell do the Emmys get off nominated The
Mandalorian? I didn’t even bother to watch it (I’ll watch some episodes to
try and catch up) but are the Emmys really just trying to get Star Wars viewers here. There were no
acting nods and no writing nods. If you’re going to nominate a sci-fi show, you
could at least nominate Westworld. The Emmys are supposed to be nominating great
dramas, like This is Us or Pose or Big Little Lies. This seems like a plea of some kind that I don’t
get… at least not yet.
OUTSTANDING ACTOR IN A DRAMA SERIES
Brian Cox,
Sterling Brown and Billy Porter more than deserve to be here. I can more than
see the logic for Jeremy Strong. And Jason Bateman’s work in Ozark is so different from every other
character he plays that he deserves to be here.
But Steve Carell
for The Morning Show? Leaving aside
that it’s hard to justify that role as a lead, I can think of at least three
other deserving nominees BEFORE we get to Bob Odenkirk. Nothing for Milo Ventimiglia or Tobias Menzies? Nothing for Paul
Giamatti or Damien Lewis? This is one of the Best Actors in a Drama. There’s no
logic here. None at all.
OUTSTANDING ACTRESS IN A DRAMA SERIES
Olivia Colman,
Jennifer Anniston and Laura Linney more than deserve to be here, and I can see
the logic of re-nominating Jodie Comer and Sandra Oh from Killing Eve.
But Zendaya for Euphoria? A series that was barely
watchable, much less viewable? Forget Nicole Kidman or Reese Witherspoon; Mandy
Moore or Viola Davis would’ve been far better choices. Claire Danes has more
depths. Evan Rachel Wood and Elisabeth Moss would make more sense No one can
honestly consider Zendaya a viable actress, much less a character in this show.
I’d say the Emmys have gone rock bottom, but...
OUTSTANDING SUPPORTING ACTOR IN A DRAMA
Now I’ll admit I
wasn’t thinking rationally when I didn’t include any nominees in this category
for Succession. Kieran Culkin and
Matthew MacFayden are extremely good in their work (I was going to include
Culkin initially). I’m not as sure about Nicholas Braun (hell, I’m not even
sure who he is). And I had no problem with Giancarlo Esposito and Billy Crudup
being picked.
But why on earth
would you give another nomination to The
Morning Show? Now I love Mark Duplass as a writer, director and actor, but
if you’re going to nominate a Supporting Actor from this show, why not put
Steve Carell here? And as big a fan as I am of Bradley Whitford and Jeffrey
Wright, they paled not only in comparison to Jonathan Banks, but to David Harbour
in Stranger Things and Mandy Patinkin
in Homeland. There is just a general
laziness here. Whitford’s gotten enough love from the Emmys, and Wright seems
lower on the list of performers on his own series. If you’re nominate someone
in Supporting, why not Ed Harris? (Hell, Wright was nominated as Best Actor
last time out, so the logic makes no sense here either). Eight nominations and
they still couldn’t get it right.
OUTSTANDING SUPPORTING ACTRESS IN A DRAMA
Laura Dern,
Meryl Streep, Helena Bonham Carter, Julia Garner and Sarah Snook. So far so
good. I’m willing to give a little leeway for Thandie Newton for Westworld because she is by far the best
thing about this often confused show.
But again,
there's so much of a mess with the final two. I didn’t see the logic is
nominating Fiona Shaw for Killing Eve last
year, and it still doesn’t make any sense. And I don’t care how good the
actresses in The Handmaid’s Tale are;
they don’t hold a candle to either Rhea Seehorn in Better Call Saul or Millie Bobby Brown in Stranger Things. Hell, I could’ve lived with Susan Kalechi Watson,
shorted again for her fine work on This
is Us. Eight should’ve been enough. You done messed it up again.
As for Guest
Actors, I’m glad to see Andrew Scott nominated, and I hope he wins to make up
for being ignored for Fleabag. Ron
Cephas Jones and James Cromwell more than deserve to be here, as does Jason
Bateman (Outsider is a limited series,
but let’s let that go. They couldn’t have found room for Dean Norris?
Guest Actress:
Laverne Cox and Cicely Tyson have earned their place here? I’m glad Cherry
Jones was nominated for Succession and
not The Handmaid’s Tale. I hope
Phylicia Rashad wins this year, and I’m glad to see Alexis Bledel back.
Tomorrow, I deal
with Watchmen, and all the other,
ahem, contenders for Best Limited Series.
No comments:
Post a Comment