Friday, February 21, 2025

Emmy Watch 2025 Phase One Concluded: My Predictions For The 2025 SAG Awards for TV

 

 

For the very worst of reasons the 2025 SAG Awards have been postponed until this Sunday. I will be watching them with eagerness on Netflix for numerous reasons, not the least of which is Kristen Bell is hosting this year.

This is not the only award show this weekend, however; the NAACP Image Awards are airing this Saturday. Since I consider them part of what I’ve labeled Phase 2 of the Emmy watch, I will deal with them next week along with the Spirit Awards for television.

At this point while I don’t expect a lot of surprise as the SAG Awards, few would deny that they have repeatedly shown the capacity to do so particularly in drama. Just last year Succession was expected to sweep all three awards but Outstanding Male Actor went to a very drunk Pedro Pascal for The Last Of Us and Outstanding Female Actor went to a barefoot Elizabeth Debicki. The same could happen here, given how the Critics Choice Awards went earlier this month.

So let’s begin with Drama:

OUTSTANDING DRAMATIC ENSEMBLE

Much as I’d like to see Slow Horses prevail here, we all know what’s going to win this prize considering it has already swept the Emmys, the Critics Choice Awards and the Golden Globes. And no one by now would say Shogun hasn’t earned it – certainly not me.

SHOULD WIN/WILL WIN: Shogun.

 

OUTSTANDING MALE ACTOR IN A DRAMA

Now obviously Hiroyuki Sanada should win this in a walk for Shogun. The problem is for three consecutive years the SAG awards has never done what it was supposed to. Succession has lost male actor both years it won Best Drama (in 2022, it lost to Lee-Jung Jae for Squid Game) and in 2023 I was certain Bob Odenkirk would win Best Male Actor but it went to Jason Bateman for Ozark. Throw in the fact that Sanada is competing against Tadanobu Asano, who like Sanada has also won both awards he’s been eligible from the Golden Globes and the Critics Choice, and there is a strong possibility they may split the vote.

I suspect Sanada will carry the day but if he doesn’t my preference is Jeff Bridges for his work in The Old Man which would be a fitting cap to a series cut down in its prime.

Should Win: Sanada/Bridges.

Will Win: Sanada.

 

OUTSTANDING FEMALE ACTOR IN A DRAMA

Two weeks ago I would have been certain Anna Sawai was going to win this award for Shogun in a walk. Then Kathy Bates won Best Actress at the Critics Choice to throw it into a cocked hate. Now my certainty has diminished.

I still think Sawai has the momentum to carry the day. But don’t rule out Bates prevailing for Matlock – considering she was also nominated for The Great Lillian Hall, I don’t know if the SAG will let her go home empty handed.

Should Win: Sawai.

Will Win: Sawai/Bates.

 

OUTSTANDING COMEDIC ENSEMBLE

As with Outstanding Dramatic Ensemble this one’s a gimme. Hacks has already swept the Golden Globes and the Critics Choice awards and is the out-and-out frontrunner for the Emmy next year. I can’t think of a more deserving winner and I can’t wait to say what everyone says.

Should Win/Will Win: Hacks,

 

OUTSTANDING MALE ACTOR IN A COMEDY

This is a tougher one by far. Jeremy Allan White prevailed in an upset at the Golden Globes for the third season of The Bear. Adam Brody won the Critics Choice Award for Nobody Wants This – but critically White wasn’t nominated. We also can’t rule out the power of Shrinking and the fact that Harrison Ford is more than deserving.

I suspect that Brody will have enough room the carry the day this time. But don’t rule out White making it a three-peat – as we will see in the next category.

Should Win: Brody/Ford.

Will Win: Brody.

 

OUTSTANDING FEMALE ACTOR IN A COMEDY

Could they give the award to Kristen Bell as she emcees? I won’t lie and say I’d love to see her win something? But let’s not kid ourselves: we know who’s going to win in this category and no one questions that she’s earned her third straight award for the third season. Jean Smart will win her third SAG award for three seasons of Hacks and is there anyone who deserves it more?

Should Win/Will Win: Smart.

 

OUTSTANDING MALE ACTOR IN A TV MOVIE/LIMITED SERIES

At this point we all know who the front runner is in this heavily loaded category. Richard Gadd’s time as the favorite for Baby Reindeer has long since passed and it is now time for Colin Farrell to continue his march towards the Emmy for his incredible work in The Penguin. The question is how great will his acceptance speech this time, as he keeps finding ways to outdo himself.

Should Win/Will Win: Farrell.

 

OUTSTANDING FEMALE ACTOR IN A TV MOVIE/LIMITED SERIES

This one may be the trickiest one of the night. Jessica Gunning is in this category for Baby Reindeer and she’s taken both Supporting Actress prizes she’s been eligible for. Jodie Foster won the Golden Globe for True Detective. Cristin Milioti won the Critics’ Choice Award for The Penguin. And though it might not count the same way Lily Gladstone did beat Gunning in this category for her work in Under The Bridge at the Critics’ Choice Awards.

First of all, all four of these nominees gave magnificent performances even in series I fundamentally did not like. But I think it will come down to either Gunning for Baby Reindeer or Milioti for The Penguin. I’d like to see Milioti prevail because her performance was closer to a lead. But I give the barest of edges to Gunning and I expect to see Milioti win at the Emmys down the road.

Should Win: Milioti.

Will Win: Gunning.

 

STUNT ENSEMBLE

A tough call among these series. I think it will come down to either Shogun or The Penguin. Now I could be wrong, having only seen bits and pieces of House of The Dragon and none of Fallout or The Boys. My preference is for Shogun but I’m willing to speak with certainty as to the rest.

 

I’ll be back with my reactions to the SAG awards – winners for TV and all – on Monday.

No comments:

Post a Comment