Friday, January 3, 2025

This is Jeopardy - Failures of The Superchampions, Part 4: Why It Took Until 2017 To Have The Next Tournament of Champions And The Rise of Two 12-Game Winners

 

Even a long time fan of Jeopardy like myself can forget its recent history such as that there was no Tournament of Champions in 2016.

There was an obvious reason for that: Jeopardy requires champions in order to have a Tournament. And between November of 2015 and April of 2016, there were none.

That is only a slight exaggeration and yet understates it. One almost wonders if Matt Jackson had placed some kind of whammy on Jeopardy when he didn’t win the Tournament of Champions. Because after Matt’s defeat the show went one of its longest stretches in its history without a single player qualifying for the Tournament. Sort of.

There were quite a few three game winners during that period and indeed three players during this period won four games. Fred Vaughn, who won $65,700 in late January; Tim Kutz, who won an impressive $107,000 dollars in late February and Todd Giese who won four games in the last week of March and just over $82,403. But for whatever reason, none of them nor anyone else could manage to make it as far as five games. During this same period Sam Deutsch managed to win the College Championship.

That said for the majority of the 2015-2016 season, no one seemed capable of winning five games on Jeopardy.

And then all of sudden everybody seemed capable of doing it. Two weeks after Todd Giese lost after winning four games Andrew Pau first appeared on Jeopardy and had the best run of any player since Matt Jackson. He won 6 games in a row and $170,202 during them. His place in Jeopardy lore has been forgotten because of the player who defeated him when he was trying for win number seven.

For reasons that are inexplicable to me, there is a group of Jeopardy fans who consider Buzzy Cohen ‘polarizing’. Perhaps it was because in his later games he didn’t take Final Jeopardy seriously and seemed to be taunting Alex Trebek doing so. Just as with those who loathed Arthur Chu during his original run I found this inexplicable. All I cared about was how well he played the game and Buzzy played it very well. He doesn’t quite fit the level of super-champion as he won ‘just’ nine games but as someone who had to come from behind as often as he ran away with victories that doesn’t make him any less impressive.

Like Arthur there was a considerable gap between appearances: after his fifth victory he had to wait three weeks for his next appearance as first the 2016 Teachers Tournament took place (it was eventually won by Jason Sterlacci, a sixth grade English Teacher) and what would be the mercifully last Power Players Week a celebrity tournament fundamentally featuring political figures whose play made every single player in SNL’s Jeopardy parodies all look like Ken Jennings by comparison. (By this point I had stopped watching these kinds of tournaments altogether.) When play resumed at the final week in May Buzzy kept on going until that Friday when he lost to Erin Delaney. He finished with $164,603 and nine wins all of which would have been the best for many Jeopardy tournaments – but would quickly be outshone.

Before the season came to an end two more players had won six games: Hunter Appier, who his run began three weeks after Buzzy’s ended and netted him $145,603 by its end and Pranjal Vachaspati, who brought to the season to a fitting conclusion winning $137,088 before his run ended the final week of the season. Still it was pretty obvious that there could be no Tournament of Champions in 2016 and perhaps not until the end of the following season.

We had to wait a full two weeks into the 2015-2016 season to get our first super-champion. We had to wait exactly one week into the 2016-2017 season for one to arrive.

Seth Wilson was a Ph.D. candidate from Chicago when he first appeared on Jeopardy to challenge Siddharth Harihan, who’d already won two games and $28,135. While he got off to a fast start in the Jeopardy round – he had $10,400 at the end of it, in Double Jeopardy it was the other challenger Dorcas Alexander who dominated and at the end of round was leading $16,800 to Seth’s $14,900 and Siddharth’s $7000.

Then came Final Jeopardy. The category was AUTHORS. “In 1948 he wrote he had an idea for a novel in which 2 guys hitchhike to California ‘in search of something they don’t really find.” Siddharth and Seth each knew the correct answer: “Who is Kerouac?” Seth wagered everything. Dorcas, however, thought it was Steinbeck. Seth Wilson had won his first game. He would win a lot more.

Seth was not as dominant a player as Matt Jackson or Arthur Chu had been in their runs: he had to earn the lion’s share of his victories: only four of his twelve wins were runaway victories and a lot of his wins were based on the fact that his opponents found the Daily Doubles ahead of him but by and large they didn’t work out.

That didn’t change the fact that Seth was very, very good when it counted. And as a result he quietly managed to win a lot. Before his fifth game he’d crossed the $100,000 threshold and on his ninth game he’d crossed the $200,000 threshold. When he won his tenth game – only the sixth player in Jeopardy history to win that may – he’d won $231,801 which at that point was the sixth highest total in earnings any player had managed in their regular run. Two days later he passed Arthur Chu for fifth place in games won with 12 and he’d managed to win $265,002. He did so with a big grin on his face and a cheerful manner throughout. He was actually leading going into his thirteenth game and responded correctly on Final Jeopardy – but a rare conservative wager worked against him and he was unseated by Margie Eulner Ott. (As is often the case, Margie lost the following day.)

It was one of the most impressive runs in Jeopardy history – and yet Seth became something that happens very rarely to super champions. By the time of his 2017 Tournament of Champions appearance he had been completely eclipsed in the imagination of the public, and perhaps even Jeopardy fans.

There were outside factors, none really having anything to do with the election that year. The biggest one was the fact that the show realized it was going to have to wait until the following November (by and large the starting period for most TOC’s) to begin play. A lot could happen in a year and indeed quite a bit did.

For one thing in December of 2016 Jeopardy back-to-back multi-champions. On December 2nd Tim Aten began a run of seven wins and $107,499. He would be defeated by Cindy Stowell who would win six games and $103,803. Cindy’s appearance was overshadowed by tragedy. She had suffered from Stage IV cancer and had been giving only months to live. In fact she never lived to see her championship run, dying on December 5th, a full eight days before her episodes aired. (I will write on her run in a later series.)

After Cindy’s defeat on December 22nd there followed the remainder of the 2016-2017 season was one of the oddest in Jeopardy history: many three game winners and only a handful of players who won exactly five games: both of them coming in the final month of the season: Jon Eisenman and Justin Vossler, each of won around $100,000 apiece. There were also two six game winners: Lisa Schlitt and Alan Lin as well as the 2017 College and Teachers Tournament Winners.

When the 2016-17 season was over Jeopardy had fourteen players who were eligible for the tournament by the standard of either the five game guarantee and the winners of the special Tournaments. Had Cindy Stowell been alive they would have had enough eligible players. The question was who got that last spot. There were five players who’d won four games since the previous Tournament of Champions in November 2015. This was unprecedented territory for the show: how did they determine who was eligible based on those standards?

I have no idea the kind of thinking that was going on with the producers behind the scenes during the off-season between Seasons 33 and 34. How they would handle it will remain a mystery – because two weeks into the new season, a new player arose that would become yet another super-champion who rose above Jeopardy itself.

Matt Jackson had become a media favorite in his original run as much because of his expressiveness in winning as his dominance as a champion. Austin Rogers managed to one-up Matt in that respect because of his similar behavior: the rapid gesticulations and gestures he did behind the podium when Johnny was introducing him. That behavior, which led him to being named one of the great viral sensations of 2017, at times overshadowed his superlative nature as a Jeopardy player.

And from the start of his run to the end he was one of the most dominant super-champions of all time. He won $36,000 in his first runaway victory which would turn out to be a light game going forward. By his fourth appearance he’d won $123,100, well ahead of any other player save Ken Jennings – and not that far behind him. On the day he officially clinched his spot in the Tournament of Champions he won $65,600 – and the very next day won $69,000.

To that point in Jeopardy history no one – not even Ken Jennings – had won that much money in back-to-back appearances. After six wins he had won more money than anyone in Jeopardy history – even Ken Jennings – had won in their first six games with $257,700. No one other that James Holzhauer has won more than that much money in their first six games since; not even Amy Schneider or Matt Amodio were anywhere near that amount.

One could call his performance behind the lectern somewhat downhill afterwards considering he ‘merely’ averaged about $25,000 a win for his next six games. Four of those games, it should be mentioned were runaways and two of them were much closer than the majority of his games. And it’s not like he – or the audience – wasn’t having a lot of fun watching him dazzle us with his superb play and gestures even though the former was letting us enjoy the latter.

But eventually Austin’s luck ran out in the form of Scarlett Simms. Scarlett got off to a faster start then him in the Jeopardy round and eventually built a lead that two correct responses on Daily Doubles could not overcome. In this case he made five mistakes along with 21 correct responses where as Scarlett only made one mistake and gave 25 correct responses. She finished with $21,200 at the end of Double Jeopardy to his $16,600. But super-champs to that point he made Scarlett work for her win.

The Final Jeopardy category was MOVIE HISTORY. “A 1947 FBI chided this holiday film’s ‘attempt to discredit bankers…a common trick used by Communists.” Austin knew the correct response: “What is It’s a Wonderful Life?” He wagered almost everything, putting him in the lead with $33,150. Scarlett however also knew the correct response and her wager of $12,001, gave her $33,001 and unseated Austin after 12 wins and $411,000.

He was now tied for fifth in most games won and money won. The difference was that in 12 games Austin had won nearly as much as Matt Jackson had won in thirteen and was very close to Julia Collins and David Madden had in 20 and 19. He’d averaged just over $34,000 a win in each of his victories, which at that point was more dominant then any super-champion in the show’s history. He didn’t have to look like he was having fun; this ‘humble New York bartender’ was clearly having fun. The fact that he had more than enough money to quit his day job and chose to keep at it made viewers like myself love him all the more.

It was less than a month before the Tournament of Champions took place but while Austin was clearly a heavy favorite (fan as much as anything) it was difficult to look at the line-up and say he had a clear advantage. Considering that there were far more six game winners competing in this tournament then five game winners and that every single competitor in this tournament had already won at least $100,000 to argue that players like Austin or Seth had an advantage because they’d won so many games would seem to be hubris. This was, if anything, a stronger field than the 2014 Tournament of Champions which had two super-champions in it. Austin was the first to learn this.

In his quarterfinal match he faced off against David Clemmons, the winner of the 2017 Teachers Tournament and Alan Lin, who’d won six games. Almost from the start of the match Alan was the dominant player and Austin was struggling throughout. At the end of the Jeopardy round Alan had a huge lead with $8800 while Austin was in a distant second with $600.

Austin got a chance to make his move early in Double Jeopardy when he found the first Daily Double in BOATS & SHIPS. Still in a distant second he wagered the $3400 he had. It didn’t go well:

“A pirogue is one type of this, a canoe made from one log.” Austin fumbled before guessing: “What is a kayak?” It was actually a dugout canoe. He did his best to regroup but the damage was done: Alan ran away with the game and had $19,605. Austin had just $8000. Austin’s only hope for getting to the semi-final was through the wild card.

The category was 19th CENTURY POETS: “In 1824 he was refused burial in Westminster Abbey for ‘questionable morality’, in 1969 he got a memorial stone there.” Austin knew the correct response: “Who was Lord Byron?” He wagered everything, giving him $16,000. Now all he could do was wait.

Seth Wilson’s turn came the next day. He was up against Lisa Schlitt, who’d also won 6 games and Sam Deutsch, the winner of the 2016 College Championship. This match was far closer then Austin’s. Lisa moved out to a big lead thanks to responding correctly in the Daily Double in the Jeopardy round and finished it with $9200. But Seth was not out of the tunning with $5600 and Sam was not far off with $4400.

Lisa managed to add to her lead when she got to the first Daily Double but Austin was close with $8000 when he found the other Daily Double in WHERE & WHEN? “The Constitution gets its first state ratification: State, year.” He got the state right – Delaware – but thought the year was 1788 instead of 1787. It cost him $2500 and dropped him into third. He was still there at the end of Double Jeopardy but it was far from a distant third: He had $9900 to Sam’s $12,400 and Lisa’s $14,400.

The Final Jeopardy category was THE GREAT DEPRESSION: “A street-corner occupation that saved many in the Depression was aided by a 1930 tops-in-the-U.S. crop in this state.” Only Lisa knew the correct state: “What is Washington?” (As Alex said: “They had a bumper crop of apples that year.” Seth thought of a farm state but it was Iowa and he lost $4501 to dropped him to $5399. Viewers at home (but not Seth) knew that whatever hope he had of a wild-card spot was gone. Austin’s, however, would be more than high enough to qualify for the semi-finals.

Austin’s semi-final opponents were 2017 College Champion (and self-proclaimed spiciest meme-lord) Lilly Chin and Andrew Pau, who’d won more money in his six games then Buzzy Cohen had in 9.  Austin had his hands full.

Both he and Andrew fought it out the entire Jeopardy round for the lead with Lilly making some major gains in the second half.  Austin had a narrow lead when the end of round buzzer rang with $6800 to Andrew’s $6000 and Lilly’s $4600.

Andrew got off to a rocket like start in Double Jeopardy getting the first five clues correct and finding the first Daily Double in WORLD PLACE NAMES on the sixth clue of the round. At that point he already had $13,600, twice Austin’s total. Perhaps wanting to try and put the game away early he bet $8000 and it backfired. He dropped to $5600.

Double Jeopardy became a war of attrition, coming down to who made the fewest mistakes. In that sense Austin did the best, only giving one incorrect response to 18 correct answers. Andrew gave 16 and gave two incorrect ones and Lilly gave thirteen correct responses but gave four incorrect ones. In both cases it was the incorrect Daily Doubles that decided the game. Austin finished Double Jeopardy with $9200 to Andrew’s $7200 and Lilly’s $6800.

The Final Jeopardy category in this wafer-thin close match was VICE PRESIDENTS. “A biography of this 19th century VP traces his family to a German town made famous in a folk tale about children.” Austn knew the correct response: “Who is Hannibal Hamlin?” (Lincoln’s first vice President, whose name was descended from Hamelin, the town of the Pied Piper.) This response would be decisive in his qualifying for the finals.

The 2017 Tournament of Champions Finals is known for the inveterate clowning of Austin, Alan Lin and Buzzy Cohen which Alex noted: “I’m dealing with three monkeys here.”  Lost under the antics was the brilliance of the three champions who had already combined to win 27 games and just under $700,000. The fact that Alan had already faced Austin and soundly thrashed him added a competitiveness to these finals that one rarely sees. And it also continued the tradition of having two of the hardest Final Jeopardys possible which stumped all three champions, myself and no doubt countless viewers at home.

In the Jeopardy round of Game 1 Austin took an early lead and managed to hold it throughout. He finished with $4800 to Buzzy’s $3000 and Alan’s $2400.

Austin held his lead for awhile in Double Jeopardy and then went to the category TRIPLE RHYME TIME. After no one got the $400 clue, he said: “This is going to be terrible.” Naturally the first Daily Double was in the very next clue in that category. Nevertheless he wagered $2800:

“A happy 10K for women in habits.”

Austin: Okay, I’m gonna put it in the right…What is a nun fun run, ooh, a fun run…oh, God. What is a nun fun run?

Alex ended his suffering. “All three were acceptable.” Austin went up to $9600. He maintained his lead for awhile but then he found the other Daily Double in PLACE ‘MAT’S. At the time he had $12,800 and wagered $4800.

“Olive you should know that this capital of the Greek department of Messenia is a major fruit market.”

Austin said: Marco Polo, I have no idea.

After Alex revealed it was Kalamata he added: “Olive’ at the beginning of the clue was a very important part.

Austin was honest. “I understand it. I just didn’t get it.

After that Alan went on a tear to take the lead and finished Double Jeopardy with $14,400 to Austin’s $10,000. Buzzy had struggled throughout the game and had only $4200.

The Final Jeopardy category was INVENTIONS. “When Time Magazine named it Invention of the Year in 2007, it was described as too slow, too big, pretty & touchy feely.”

No one gave the correct answer though Austin came the closest – and then backed away from it. He wrote down: “What is the iPhone?” crossed it out and wrote down “iPad” instead.” As Alex pointed out, he should’ve stuck with his first choice because it was the iPhone. Alan wrote down the iPad as well and Buzzy wrote down the Tesla model S. I’m note sure what I thought it was: I think I was torn between both of Austin’s guesses.

Austin ended up wagering the least of all three players. He lost $3500. Buzzy bet the $4200 he had and Alan lost $5600. At the end of Day  Alan was in the lead with $8800 to Austin’s $6500 and while Buzzy had nothing, if he played well in Game 2 he had more than a fighting chance.

In the Jeopardy round of Game 2 Austin got off to a fast start when he found the Daily Double in the MUSIC GROUPS DEFINED. He bet the $1800 he had: “On a standard piano, there are 36 of these, sharps & flats.” Austin knew they were the Black Keys and doubled his score. Alan narrowed the gap however and he and Austin spent the rest of the round fighting for the lead. When the end of round buzzer rang Austin still had it $6200 to Alan’s $5600 while Buzzy had $2800.

Austin held his lead for a little while in Double Jeopardy but then Buzzy and Alan began to take command. When Buzzy found one of the Daily Doubles early in the round, he had $10,800. Knowing the ground he needed to make up he bet everything and it worked out for him. Alan got to the other Daily Double later in the round, bet the $10,400 he had – and it didn’t go his way.

When the end of round buzzer range, Buzzy had $25,600 in front of him. Alan had only $1200 and had no chance of anything other than second place. However Austin had $10,200 and was still alive. If he got Final Jeopardy right and wagered enough and Buzzy was incorrect, he would win the Tournament of Champions.

The Final Jeopardy category sounded deceptively easy: STATE CAPITALS. It may have been the most difficult deciding Final Jeopardy in a TOC for a very long time.

“A state capital since 1805, its name begins with the last four letters of the state’s name.” No one could come close to a guess, though Austin made an effort when he wrote down: “What is Indianapolis?” That cost him $10,000. The correct response was Montpelier, the capital of Vermont. Buzzy didn’t take it seriously and lost $1301. As a result he won the Tournament of Champions and a quarter of a million dollars. By risking everything Austin had a combined total of $6700, which ended with him in third place and $50,000.

The next article will be a brief interlude in which I state my personal reflections on the super-champions just prior to the rise of James Holzhauer.

 

No comments:

Post a Comment